4 ms·
Is there a reason @JadeMasterMath's comment doesn't generalise the list?
by 082349872349872 4y ago
Is there a reason @JadeMasterMath's comment doesn't generalise the list?
- red_trumpet 4y agoWhat makes you think it doesn't? It certainly generalises some of Tao's points, but I lack the expertise to judge all of them. Also, Tao's list provides lots of helpful examples, not everyone might be easily able to see their problem through the lense of JadeMasterMath's comment.
- 082349872349872 4y agoI have no reason (also lacking expertise to judge all); I found it a good summary and that's why I ask if anyone else has a reason. Good point about the examples. There's an ancient injunction to not multiply examples unnecessarily, but in this day and age of general literacy and nearly free storage, we probably do well to offer a grand variety of examples and let readers pick and choose the ones they wish to contemplate.
- isaacfrond 4y agoHa, I snagged on that one to. Obviously what he is saying is true, but is add nothing. It like saying, to prove A, find a structure B, and exploit it. It is 100% true but helps you nothing. The beauty of Tao's list is that he gives actual examples. And many of them too.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- hgsgm 4y agoIt generalizes even further: If you need to prove B, and you know A implies B, all you need to prove is A.
- mcphage 4y agoIt does, but it really isn't actionable in the same way. Given a specific structure, you need to know what the generators are for that structure, and so that ends up being a list of "if you've got this structure... then you need to check ..."—which is exactly what Tao provided.