4 ms·
"However, extensive sea trials carried out by US website boattest.com on the new Sharrow Propeller MX-1 seem to confirm all of the above and show efficiency gai
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
"However, extensive sea trials carried out by US website boattest.com on the new Sharrow Propeller MX-1 seem to confirm all of the above and show efficiency gains of between 9-15% over comparable 3-blade propeller designs.
The tests were carried out on a 20ft Bayliner VR5 sportsboat fitted with a standard Mercury 150hp outboard engine, comparing Sharrow’s new tipless MX-1 against two market leading-competitors. Not only was it the fastest of the three (41.7 knots vs 40.8 knots and 39.0 knots) and the most efficient (4.6mpg @ 32 knots vs 4.2mpg and 4.1mph), it also planed earlier and outperformed them both at every 500rpm increment from idle speed to wide open throttle."
Seems like the title is incorrect? The article only claims 9-15% mileage improvements along with vibration reduction and handling improvements.
- idiotsecant 4y agoNo, it claims 9 to 15% efficiency gains. A more efficient machine, with all else being equal, is more powerful at that same engine condition.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoEfficieny gains of boat propulsion translates into mileage gains... unless boats work in some non-linear manner?
- idiotsecant 4y agoImagine you have a propeller with an efficiency of 50% at a particular differential pressure. What happens to that lost 50%? It turns into heat. Now imagine you have a fancy new propeller with an efficiency of 99% at that particular differential pressure. All that energy that you were using making heat before is not turning into thrust. Your overall engine-propeller system is now twice as powerful at that same differential pressure.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoOkay, and?
- VLM 4y agoSmall sport boats usually operate way above hull speed in the the far non-linear region so an extra ten percent thrust will result in a far non-linear increase in speed. I'd believe an extra 15% of thrust would only make it 2% faster. Really small boats with really huge engines can push quite a bit past hull speed at ultra low efficiency, and that's the only numerical stats they're providing in the article, which is interesting. I wonder if performance is just as high at low speeds, below hull speed, where most cargo ships operate and all the marketing greenwashing is occurring. Hull speed is not "supersonic" but its a similar enough to rhyme concept, where the boat has a tough time pushing up or thru its own bow wave, sort of, so the max speed of a boat is mostly related to its length. Oddly enough the hydrodynamic variables all cancel out or whatever such that mostly all that matters is wetted hull length for hull speed. You'd superficially guess something like hull depth would matter or width or shape kind of like the stall speed of an airplane wing depends on its shape, but no, ships hull speed almost entirely depends on the wetted hull length. Just a weird hydrodynamics thing. Maybe an air craft carrier with 10 times the power could go 5% faster, but it would take 100x the power to get an AC carrier up on plane like a ski boat.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoHowever engines are roughly linear in displacement vs power output. A 15% increase in thrust would mean you can reduce the displacement of the engine by 15% and maintain the same speed. This would be compounded by the weight savings, smaller fuel tank, etc. However, I think there is a far less than 15% increase in thrust, and due to the super-linear loss of efficiency at the top end to get a 15% increase in efficiency for the same output level might only require a 3% or so increase in thrust at that output level.