8 ms·
I bought a used car from Carvana before the pandemic, and this is pretty sad news to me because after that purchase I vowed that all my future cars would come f
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I bought a used car from Carvana before the pandemic, and this is pretty sad news to me because after that purchase I vowed that all my future cars would come from Carvana. The buying experience was simply excellent for me, and I couldn't be happier with the car I bought. I figured I probably could have gotten a comparable deal slightly cheaper somewhere else, but I would have wasted a ton of time, and still would have crossed my fingers that I wasn't buying a lemon - any slight premium I paid to Carvana I felt was totally worth it.
I hope they can fix their financial issues (sounds like they just "bought high and are selling low") and their operational issues (in some places word got out that it was cheaper to just "buy" a Carvana car and then return it < 7 days rather than getting a car rental), because, at least for me, their purchasing experience was great.
- moralestapia 4y agoThe problem with Carvana's valuation is that car dealerships run on thin margins. It's very hard to make billions out of that.
- KennyBlanken 4y ago...and this translated into very poor quality vehicles because they couldn't afford proper inspections and repairs (don't have to fix what you don't find! Let the customer sort it out! And be incredibly annoying to contact, so they maybe just go away...ie the Google model of customer service!) and their on-the-road staff were horribly trained. There are multiple videos out there of Carvana staff dropping people's "new" cars off the backs of the flatbed trucks. I remember seeing the ads for them hiring delivery drivers and it amounted to "have a pulse? friendly? We'll train you to drive a large commercial vehicle and load/unload cars, wooo!" If I remember correctly they were banned from car sales in multiple states, in some cases states banning them multiple times: https://www.google.com/search?q=carvana+banned+in+what+states https://www.google.com/search?q=carvana+banned+in+what+state...
- bsagdiyev 4y agoNot sure why you were downvoted. They got their Raleigh (Wake County) license revoked for a while for selling cars with Virginia, South Carolina and Georgia titles IN North Carolina. Cars weren't passing basic safety inspection and sometimes they didn't even provide the title after months! Transferring an out of state title in NC hits you with a road tax up to a defined upper limit ($400 I believe is the absolute highest) based on car value and state you transfer from, so they likely did this to avoid paying that sales tax themselves before selling the car. It's shady as hell.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThis is the problem when SV startup approaches hit the world of physical products. This isn't software. To sell a car, you first have to buy one. You cannot create them out of bits and sell more at nearly zero marginal cost. Your inventory has a carrying cost. You're playing in a market. Carvana got caught buying high and having to sell low. Was there any securities trading firm or auto retailer experience on their management team or board?
- freeopinion 4y agoI have several issues with your comment. 1. What makes you think car dealerships run on thin margins? I don't know what typical margins are, but the owners seem to do pretty well. This may be despite low margins. But I'm reluctant to accept your claim without proof. 2. What qualifies as low margin? 1%? 10%? 3. It is entirely possible to make billions on low margins. A dealer that makes $1000 per car can make $1 billion profit by selling 1 million cars. If the average car sells for $15k, a $1k profit would be a < 7% margin. See question 2 about low margins. A little mom-and-pop lot in a very small town can sell 5-10 cars per month. It doesn't seem unreasonable for a huge national online dealership to sell 1 million cars. 4. What timeframe are we talking? Five years? Carmax financials say they do more than $5 billion in a single quarter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- twelve40 4y agonot the parent, but they probably meant "compared to typical vc-funded startup expected margins". most faangs don't need to ship tons of steel to anybody and their margins are around 25%. can you disrupt used cars given all the logistics of the physical world? maybe, I don't know, but people here report both carmax and carvana having severe business issues, why?
- freeopinion 4y agoTypical vc-funded startups have negative margins.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoDon't disagree with the sentiment that selling physical products is a lot more intensive than a SaaS app, but to this point, "people here report both carmax and carvana having severe business issues" is definitely due to the whiplash in the used car business due to COVID. That is, both new and used car prices skyrocketed due to supply chain issues, so CarMax and Carvana had to pay a ton for their inventory. Now car prices are "normalizing", so both of these companies have high priced inventory that they now need to sell in a low(er) priced market.
- mr90210 4y agoLook up Joshua Fluke on YouTube, on one of his last videos he talks in details about the legal issues that Carvana has had.
- lokar 4y agoI’ve heard that before, and always wondered: how dealership owners are able to buy so much power in state capitals?
- xxpor 4y agoOutside of large cities, car dealership owners are usually some of the people with the most money. See also: beverage distributers https://patrickwyman.substack.com/p/american-gentry https://patrickwyman.substack.com/p/american-gentry
- linksnapzz 4y agoA century of practice.
- PLenz 4y agoThe GM streetcar conspiracy basically gave dealerships to already politically connected individuals in return for killing off streetcars - the payoff being that the busses that replaced (poorly, hence encouraging private car ownership) would be bought via the dealerships. Car dealership owners are often car dealership owners because of adjacency to power, not the reverse.
- slt2021 4y agothat explains all the sleazy sales practices coming from stealerships. regulatory capture + dishonest sleazy sales practices = happy middleman, but suffering consumer and car manufacturer
- vkou 4y agoThe same way that your local real estate development firms own your town's politics. They care more about government then literally anyone else in the area, and nobody else has as strong a financial incentive to politically push back on what they want.
- phphphphp 4y agoThe good experience you had early on and the bad state of the company now are closely linked. The story is always the same with this type of company: take a mature industry that is profitable on a unit basis because it’s boring and unpleasant, then build a narrative around some strategy to make it exciting (giant vending machines!) and get buy-in to spend huge amounts of money in pursuit of the narrative but eventually discover the only way to be profitable is to do what the mature industry players already discovered — but now you’ve got so much debt to service you have to cut even more corners and somehow manage to spend billions on becoming a worse version of what already existed and whatever goodwill you earned is burned. There’s lots of room for businesses to improve on the boring legacy industries with low margins — like car buying and selling — but it requires careful iteration, it requires taking the established understanding and then building on it. Subsidising the cost of good-but-unprofitable service using investment dollars (Carvana was losing thousands per sale pre-pandemic) doesn’t build a sustainable business unless it’s part of a strategy.
- avalys 4y agoYeah, exactly. "I loved Carvana because I bought a great car from them at a better price than the legacy players!" and "I loved Carvana because they bought my used car at a really good price!" Guess what? Buying cars for too much money and selling them for too little money means they go out of business.
- maria2 4y ago> "I loved Carvana because I bought a great car from them at a better price than the legacy players!" That's literally the opposite of what the GP said: > The buying experience was simply excellent for me, and I couldn't be happier with the car I bought. I figured I probably could have gotten a comparable deal slightly cheaper somewhere else, but I would have wasted a ton of time I mean this politely, but did you really read what you were replying to?
- bluedino 4y agoI think he was quoting the typical Carvana customer, not the parent poster
- tptacek 4y agoFor what it's worth, I felt the same way about Carmax, last year. Bought online, they drove the car out to me, and when a better trim of the same car popped up on their site 2 weeks later, I just traded it sticker-for-sticker no questions asked. I'm sure I didn't get close to the best price, but I got better than dealership sticker for the make/model/year, and I lost zero time to the transaction.
- faddypaddy34 4y agoI have bought almost all of my cars from CarMax in the last decade. Even going into their dealerships in person is not a typical experience. There is no negotiation on price and the only "upsell" was their extended warranty. They are also hemorrhaging money currently and hopefully don't go the way of carvana.
- theGnuMe 4y agoI bought through carmax and I call it dealership lite. They tried to finance me even though I already had financing (and I said no) and pushed the extended warranty pretty hard. It is like $5k for 150k miles. I've heard you should buy it if you go for a BMW, jaguar or other higher maintenance car.
- hajile 4y agoJust one car auction company (a subsidiary of Cox) controls 80-90% of the market. If a dealer avoids junk, ungraded cars, then the quality is very standardized. As a result of a completely centralized pseudo-monopoly, actual acquisition cost is set to an extreme degree (car auction price ranges are so tight that top and bottom bids are usually within a hundred dollars of each other from very cheap to very expensive vehicles). In turn, this means that local pricing is going to be based on other stuff like time on lot (more time = more payments and interest), lot space cost, sales cost, etc) Places like Carmax buy a car, mark it up $2k, and sell it making most of their money on financing and warranty/service stuff. They mark vehicles down something like $500 each month for two months then put it right back on the auction if it doesn't sell (so you'll generally get better deals from vehicles that have been on-lot a while). This is why they refuse to negotiate price. You may get a slightly better price than the dealership, but not by much when you consider every single factor. If you want the best possible deal, know the car you're looking for and offer a fixed finder's fee to a mom and pop used dealership to buy it for you. A lot of these smaller dealers will give you a good, fixed rate because it's guaranteed money to them without that normal overhead. It may not be strictly allowed (due to NDAs and such), but some may even allow you to help pick out the vehicle to bid on.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI wonder if it's possible for these concepts to really go big. The problem is, there's a lot more lemons on the market then there's great deals. Nobody wants the car that doesn't start twice a week or that's been in an accident and has its chassis skewed. These sites start out by promoting seller karma or something but even the best sellers have lemons to get rid of. At the start they probably just sell them elsewhere to keep their rating high. Eventually as these sites get so big you can't avoid them, the quality will inevitably drop because they capture too big of a market which just includes a lot of crap. At the same time investors will want to see that exponentially skyrocketing line continuing so they'll be pushing to cut corners left right and center just as things get difficult. I don't know Carvana as I don't drive much anymore but I assume the same story supplies here at least in some ways.
- ethbr0 4y agoAka the AirBNB problem. In a nutshell, that you can't have a high quality growth company forever in an industry with a fixed supply of high quality items. Initially, you grow like crazy and with great user reviews, as you're able to pick and choose the highest quality items. Unfortunately, at some point you exhaust the supply at a given quality level, but your valuation mandates continued growth. So you lower your quality requirements to obtain more supply, which only buys you a bit more time until you hit the next supply limit. The only winning move seems to be stay private and accept there's a near-term cap on your revenue growth, after which you will grow much more slowly (at the natural supply expansion rate).
- GekkePrutser 4y ago> So you lower your quality requirements to obtain more supply, which only buys you a bit more time until you hit the next supply limit. And at the same time you start burning all the goodwill that make you so popular to begin with. Thanks for explaining it more clearly, I don't really have a business head.
- ncallaway 4y ago> The only winning move seems to be stay private and accept there's a near-term cap on your revenue growth, after which you will grow much more slowly (at the natural supply expansion rate). Or go multi-brand, and introduce cheaper brands for the lower quality properties, to maintain the goodwill for the higher quality brands. Many hotels do this with many different brands under the same organization that segment their customers on price and quality expectations. I always thought that Uber/AirBnB etc should be more aggressive in creating more brand separation between their cheaper options and their higher quality options.
- kreitje 4y agoI bought one from them about 3 months ago and it was excellent. I couldn’t get a local dealership to give me the sticker price of a car on their website without showing up in person. I expected all the extra fees they throw in to be hidden but all they would post was MSRP and to call for the price. I call and they pretend to not know the car I am talking about and need to go there to see the specific car. This was multiple dealers. Carvana though showed me the price, shipping if any, taxes, tag, title before I even tried to buy it.
- jjav 4y ago> The buying experience was simply excellent for me No doubt, because a company that operates at a loss on VC money and passes the savings on to the consumer, can easily provide a great experience/price. Take advante of those companies while they exist, but be clear that they can't continue for very long. Either VC money runs out and they disappear or they go public and must start making a profit by increasing prices and slashing service.