4 ms·
Robots are the better option - we send a lot more robots to space than we do humans. But there's nothing wrong with also having some human missions.
by zozbot234 4y ago
Robots are the better option - we send a lot more robots to space than we do humans. But there's nothing wrong with also having some human missions.
- hollerith 4y agoThere's nothing wrong with having some human missions, but I don't want to help pay for it.
- btgeekboy 4y agoNASA's total budget is approximately one half of one percent (0.5%) of the federal budget. Even at its peak in the 1960s, it never reached 5%. Seems pretty reasonable.
- hollerith 4y agoSince you think it's so reasonable, would you please pay my share? If distributed equally among the US population, it is about $75 a year per person, which of course comes out to about $6.25 a month.
- whateveracct 4y agoI wonder if that's actually your share given your tax bracket though. I'm actually not familiar enough to guess.
- Aperocky 4y agoNow here comes a completely unreasonable (maybe not) idea: Democratized budget. Every year tax payers specify where their tax money goes. 50% of their taxes will go directly where they decreed it be. The other 50% and any debt can be allocated by the congress. There should also be options of "Let congress handle it" and "whatever the previous years makeup was" and options to adjust from there. NASA will probably be better funded, by a huge margin.
- btgeekboy 4y agoAt what cost though? What programs would suffer funding decreases? This is why we elect representatives. It’s not a perfect system but the average citizen would not have the context necessary to make direct decisions on it.
- pfdietz 4y agoI like this approach. If we divide the federal budget into sufficiently small chunks, all the spending is reasonable, and we don't have to worry about deficits and such. Utterly brilliant reasoning!
- avmich 4y agoIt might be hard to believe, but for space projects bigger than some scale using people is actually cheaper than sending robots. The big reason for that is that the robots are very modest in their overall capabilities. With humans, you can't get cheaper than the cost of sending one, or better few, people, but when you cross that line, you suddenly have a lot of functionality for free.
- generj 4y agoI agree. People underestimate the scientific abilities and flexibility of a highly trained technician, particularly on solid planets and moons. A human living on Mars could operate multiple geographic exploration rovers at much higher speeds than currently (existing rovers get 0.1mph max). This is the benefit of having a 60ms ping time instead of 6-20 minutes. Plus the ability to troubleshoot, clean off solar panels, run slightly different analyses without needing to build it into the probe 8 years ago, assemble sensor stations, etc. Yes the mass budgets for manned missions are titanic. But with even half-way good mission planning we can get more science done than the equivalent mass of robots - at least for Mars and the Moon. Food and life support mass for long trips to the outer planets (or shielding for Mercury) mean robots will win there.
- m4rtink 4y agoOnce you get some off Earth mining going, the mass requirements should hopefully get manageable for most places.