46 ms·
I think you're not understanding my question. You said that the most exciting feature of JPEG XL is the ability to losslessly encode old JPEGs. My point is that
by maria2 4y ago
I think you're not understanding my question. You said that the most exciting feature of JPEG XL is the ability to losslessly encode old JPEGs. My point is that, if this is the most exciting feature, then it's unsurprising that the industry is choosing to ignore JPEG XL as the "most exciting feature" is more or less useless.
Technology is a means to an end. Transcoding images is a means. The end is what you do with it. In the 90s and early 2000s, encoding images in JPEG allowed for digital cameras to store vastly more images on their limited storage space. Bandwidth was extremely limited, so JPEG encoding allowed for detailed images to be shared over the web, which wouldn't have been possible in a different format. Today, however, storage and bandwidth are cheap. JPEG already does a decent enough job for old images. Making old images even smaller isn't really enabling any new "ends."
I guess the ultimate question I'm asking is "Why do you want your old JPEGs to be smaller?" What is the end you hope to achieve with smaller JPEGs?
- JyrkiAlakuijala 4y agoSmaller is what compression is for.
- maria2 4y agoAnd there are other codecs that compress similarly to JPEG XL that also support other features like animation. So, again, why would I use JPEG XL? But anyway, this conversation was helpful. I guess there aren't really many reasons to use JPEG XL.
- JyrkiAlakuijala 4y agoThere are no such similar codecs. Jpeg xl is in its own category in compression efficiency when rated by users at densities/qualities used in the internet. Roughly similar efficiency steps between libjpeg-turbo, WebP, AVIF and then jpeg xl.
- iopq 4y agoJXL has the feature set that is better than any other solution. Killer feature #1 is compressing existing JPEG images. Nothing else can do this Killer feature #2 is HDR images with over 10 bits of depth and high resolution. It comes out of your camera/phone already like this but we can't post it online! What a joke