11 ms·
It's not a big deal, because it's so expensive it's a dead end. The problem has always been making human space flight cheap enough that it can lead to activiti
by pfdietz 4y ago
It's not a big deal, because it's so expensive it's a dead end. The problem has always been making human space flight cheap enough that it can lead to activities with positive return. The Apollo and Shuttle eras failed in that respect. SLS, by not reducing launch costs, continues in that sad and aggravating tradition.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThe massive cost comes from defeating gravity and getting stuff off of this planet. Cost reductions probably won't happen until the ISS turns into an orbital city with spacecraft manufacturing capabilities. The JWST engineers talked about the importance of building future telescopes and spacecrafts in space, it's a very important technological milestone for humanity. Mass drivers and orbital elevators are common in fiction but I don't know what the scientific consensus is on the viability of such structures.
- pfdietz 4y agoYour argument is obviously wrong. If that were the case, all launch systems would have the same cost per kg, since they all are operating on the same planet with the same gravity. But in fact, the minimum cost imposed by gravity (the energy needed to get into space) is incredibly low. The minimum fuel cost is a very small fraction of the cost of launching with current launch vehicles. The costs come from expendability and manufacturing and non-fuel operating costs. None of these are dictated by gravity.
- FPGAhacker 4y agoThere is a cost in mass. Rockets today are essentially a giant fuel tank with a few engines connected to one side and cargo connected to the other side. Every kg of fuel is a kg of cargo you can’t launch. That’s the cost.
- pfdietz 4y agoNone of that justifies claiming the cost is due to gravity. The problem of getting to space is obviously affected by gravity, but the cost is dictated by other considerations. It's not like "oh well, gravity, we might as well give up because it's not possible to do much better."
- FPGAhacker 4y ago> None of that justifies claiming the cost is due to gravity. Where do you suppose the need for so much energy comes from?
- FeepingCreature 4y agoIt's more that the cost in money doesn't come from the cost in energy.
- DarmokJalad1701 4y agoCongressional mandates forcing NASA to use Space Shuttle components for the SLS that are de facto non-competitive, single-source requirements assuring contracts to existing Shuttle suppliers is contributing significantly to the costs. For example, the NASA contract to Aerojet Rocketdyne to manufacture RS-25 engines is costing $146 million per engine. Each SLS launch will toss four of these engines in the ocean for a total cost $580 million. And that's just the engines of the core stage. For the cost of a single engine, they could have instead purchased an entire Falcon Heavy launch, which has two-thirds of the SLS lift capacity (and has to obey the same laws of physics as SLS). SLS is the price NASA had to pay to get Congress off its back.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWhy would the US congress mandate stuff like this?
- ambicapter 4y ago
- matheusmoreira 4y agoHow is it wrong? Everything I've ever read about the subject says that because of the rocket equation you need massive amounts of fuel to lift up the fuel itself and the payload to get off the ground and into orbit. In order to burn that fuel, you need complex multistage rockets which require expensive materials and precision manufacturing. Of course it's expensive. Surely if these things were built in space instead engineers would be able to build simpler, cheaper spacecrafts.
- pfdietz 4y agoRockets are not expensive because they use lots of fuel. Sit down and actually compute how much propellant is needed, and how much it costs. It's CHEAP, especially if you use LOX + hydrocarbons (as Falcon 9 and Heavy do). The actual amount of energy needed to reach LEO is about the same as the amount of energy needed to send the same mass to New Zealand from the US by airliner. The reason launch is expensive is because the launchers were thrown away. SpaceX radically reduced the cost by reusing the first stage multiple times. And there's more juice to be squeezed from that lemon, as the second stage is still being expended.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> The actual amount of energy needed to reach LEO is about the same as the amount of energy needed to send the same mass to New Zealand from the US by airliner. Yeah but rockets use a lot more fuel mass compared to aircraft whose engines are airbreathing. Rocket engines need to carry their own oxygen in the fuel tanks and are less efficient as a result. Surely fuel costs are no trivial concern. > The reason launch is expensive is because the launchers were thrown away. Well I agree that it's stupid to just throw away the rockets into the ocean but I thought NASA just didn't have the capability to reuse them. A comment below says the US congress forced them to reuse old parts which makes no sense to me.
- tinco 4y agoThat's exactly pfdietz's complaint. NASA employs the same types of humans SpaceX does. If reusability was a design constraint they would have solved it like SpaceX did. But they didn't consider it a priority or even a goal to make regular moon travel feasible so they continue throwing away billions with such limited impact.
- Aperocky 4y agoIt is not wrong, you can reduce the cost but it will never be economical simply due to the gravity well. > the minimum cost imposed by gravity (the energy needed to get into space) is incredibly low. This is straight up false.
- pfdietz 4y agoNope, you're completely wrong. Do the math. Propellant cost is a tiny fraction of the cost of a launch, even on the partially reusable Falcons.
- Aperocky 4y agoThat fraction is still larger than the economical utilization of space. Think about how little propellant it takes to move products on Earth. And that's not even counting for the fact that transport vehicles on Earth runs a heavy percentage of its life time while a rocket does not do that. Even Falcons spend most of their time getting ready or recycled and not on an ascend or descend trajectory. Any real trade will not happen at these gravity tax rates.
- epicureanideal 4y agoBut a 747 needs continued fuel to keep going whereas once on target a spacecraft can use its initial velocity to travel much much further.
- pfdietz 4y ago> That fraction is still larger than the economical utilization of space. What does this sentence even MEAN? There are economical uses of space at today's launch costs. There would be even more such uses if launch costs were a few times the cost of propellant, as the cost of air travel is. I get the feeling you are not thinking clearly on this subject.
- Aperocky 4y agoIf launch cost were few times the cost of propellant, what economic activities become feasible in space? Sending tourists? Sure, tourists are already up there and it costs even less propellant to drop to the ocean floor but not many people/business seemed to be doing that. Maybe with the exception of oil platforms. Speaking of which, what oil platform will be of space? Even a floating city in space that is purely afforded by the tourist spending generates no true economic value up there - all of it is being essentially propped up by the ground. What economic incentive are there? The only way out is to manufacture IN SITU, sourcing from locally or gravitationally less burdensome locations, like the asteroid belt. It takes less deltaV to go to the asteroid belt from LEO than it takes to get to LEO from the ground. Trust me I've been thinking about this plenty - though probably not to any use.
- Gwypaas 4y agoThe Falcon 9 is ~500 tons of propellant for 25 tons to LEO. An A380 carries ~250 tons of fuel. In the Falcon 9 number the liquid oxygen is included. The RP-1 is a pretty much a cleaner diesel or jet fuel. The cost is like $1500 to $2000 per ton so like $500 000 to $1 000 000 in fuel costs for a launch. Fuel costs are still trivial compared to building and operating the rocket and is where huge reductions are possible.
- kunai 4y agoAt the very least, Artemis is a functional space launch system with exceptional reliability and predictability despite its insane costs. The wasted billions are an embarrassment, but far less so now that we know a) the thing works, and works pretty darned well and b) it is, for now, the only game in town in its class. Starship is an interesting project with a lot of ambitious goals, but it is far behind schedule in terms of development and the Raptors are suffering from a lot of issues that Merlins didn't have due to SpaceX's inexperience with cryogenic fuels. So the question to be asked is: do we want an pricey but reliable and proven solution now, or do we hold out for years in the promise of some intangible futurist idea that will likely take far longer than anticipated to become a viable solution for crewed travel? If your answer is B, then it's fairly obvious you're less interested in the rapid progression of space travel writ large and more interested in ensuring a project you favor wins out. In a perfect world, SLS would be a rapidly reusable rocket with 5 RS-25s, an inflatable heatshield, F-1 derived liquid boosters, and landing legs. But that's not the world we live in, and something > nothing, in my opinion. And I also find it important to put the price of SLS/Artemis in context to other far more wasteful government projects that produce no surplus economic value for people, like the F-35 program or the B-21 (questionable benefit over existing defense systems). In that context, SLS is almost utilitarian, providing valuable scientific jobs to engineers and scientists, while propelling the way to the Moon for this generation's astronauts and explorers.
- pfdietz 4y agoExceptional reliability? How can you possibly claim that? Reliability comes from working out all the unknown unknowns, and that comes only from experience. Starship is not needed to condemn SLS. Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy are sufficient to render SLS uncompetitive and unneeded. In a perfect world, SLS would have had a stake driven through its corrupt programmatic heart years ago.
- zardo 4y agoIn a perfect (space policy) world, SLS wouldn't have had major components determined by the legislature. It's extremely expensive because that's what the legislature asked for, a single use rocket built using super expensive engines designed for a reusable rocket.
- no_wizard 4y agoIsn't the true "ideal" a space elevator so you can continously deliver between the moon and the earth without having to burn lots of resources every single time? Shouldn't that be what we optimize for in the long run? Its the only way I can think of that space cargo becomes economical. Then you can ship raw material up to the Moon and build from there, launch from there etc. and vice versa. Maybe we'll see what Helium-3 can do for humans at that point
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYeah, a space elevator would be the most efficient way lift payloads to space where it's a lot easier to maneuver. Anyone knowledgeable about space elevators on HN? I wonder why it's never been attempted.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoThere are currently insurmountable materials science limitations, and even the materials that come close are not currently possible to manufacture at scale, or even assemble (one carbon nanotubes does not necessarily have the same properties of many carbon nanotubes) at scale into structures which will withstand the structural stresses. I believe this is not necessarily true for other celestial objects besides the earth
- Smaug123 4y agoFor example, Pluto and Charon is a pair that sometimes comes up; a space elevator connecting Pluto to Charon would very possibly just about be within our current civilisation's capabilities, if for some reason we cared to build one enough to sink the Earth's economic output into it. They're tidally locked. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator has its section on "Extraterrestrial elevators".)
- actionfromafar 4y agoA space elevator for our own moon would be far more interesting to me. It could be built with known materials.
- LightG 4y agoWell, the US needed alternatives to Russian rockets, hence SpaceX and SLS. Now NASA need alternatives to Musk, so SLS is a good back up option. * canned laughter * (only semi joking considering his Ukraine starlink BS)
- imglorp 4y agoSetting aside his BS, there's a chasm of difference between SpaceX and SLS: it's process. SLS designs ONE (mostly) disposable ship, per year, max, taking a decade to integrate and realize. Epic Waterfall. They have several concurrent pipelines. Meanwhile SpaceX designs a reusable ship factory. Scalable to as many a year as you can afford.
- LightG 4y agoI know. But it's still space travel at the whim of a BS'er. Hence, the need for a back up or private competitor. Ideally as efficient. If not, then at almost any cost is the only alternative (NASA).