6 ms·
Google One VPN is a big deal, and potentially as big a nightmare for shady data brokers as the iOS cookie apocalypse was for Facebook and others. Google One was
by xnx 4y ago
Google One VPN is a big deal, and potentially as big a nightmare for shady data brokers as the iOS cookie apocalypse was for Facebook and others. Google One was available to paid subscribers on Android, then on Windows, and Mac. Now some Pixel owners can use it. Imagine if they turn it on for all Chrome OS users, or all Chrome mobile users, or all Chrome users period. You can have your suspicions about Google, but I'd trust them over any other tech company or VPN provider.
- WanderPanda 4y agoCan you elaborate why you trust them over Apple?
- xnx 4y agoProbably a tie with Apple. I like that Apple isn't trying to sell my attention (yet), but I do prefer the higher level of openness from Google (Android, Chrome, open source contributions, etc.)
- brodock 4y agoApple have their ads business already, it's a matter of time until profits from that business become big enough that shareholders demand changes. You can't have and Ads business and defend privacy at the same time
- dathinab 4y agoMaybe due to Apple acts in/wrt. China. People somehow end up thinking Apple cares deeply about their private but AFIK Apple only cares about privacy because it makes them money. Or more specifically the image it creates helps them in selling phones.But the moment the _long term_ cost outweighs the benefits they also have shown to bail. (I highlighted long terms because there had been case where short term it was more expensive because it e.g. involved legal cases, but especially this legal cases are a grate image profit form them as people will use it like "don't worry see they didn't even brake their security to help the police with <insert arrested very bad person>"). Now that doesn't mean Apple is bad to some degree it's a win win for the user: They get better privacy and Apple gets more users. But it doesn't mean you can fully trust Apple (or IMHO any Company).
- Spooky23 4y agoGoogle’s approach to China is the same realpolitik as Apple and privacy. Google was never going to get what it wanted/needed in China, so walking away was a pragmatic stance projected as an act of courage, etc. Google and Apple are actually more similar than one would thing. They are both leveraging their ownership of powerful segments, and they are both threatened by integrated software stacks. The big difference is that Google does creepy shit as a first party, and Apple outsources that to third parties. Google’s ad business was hurt by Facebook/Instagram and the dearb of the web. Apple’s existential threat is someone making WeChat for the US.
- akimball 4y ago...and his name is Musk.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y ago> Apple’s existential threat is someone making WeChat for the US. It's called Signal.
- Spooky23 4y agoWeChat in China is like early 1990s era AOL or Prodigy for smartphones - it’s a vertical solution. Signal is an encrypted messenger that have bolted on some crypto bullshit. It’s just a nerd tool.
- NamTaf 4y agoThey are only vaguely similar in the remotest of ways and certainly not with respect to what the OP meant, so not really.
- dathinab 4y agono, if you look at relevance today Signal is not relevant. The technical excellency is lost on most users. The demography which cares about that excellency also has a large degree of people which don't want a future with a western variant of WeChat. Because it's basically only working with monopolization. And the fact that signal pushed some crypto is not helping it either. Firstly to many non technical people have lost too much money by either crypto scams or crashes. Then their crypto currency had some questionable technical details AFIK, but I forgot the details. Then regulatory capture of crypto currencies is guaranteed incoming in the coming years (to many scams, market manipulation, hidden high risk investment and usage for crimes especially money laundering) and as far I can tell their coin will likely not get a pass.
- innocentoldguy 4y ago
- maximinus_thrax 4y ago
- foota 4y agoYou pay for the vpn
- humanistbot 4y ago
- jefftk 4y agoGP said "unless it enables a direct revenue stream", parent was pointing out that it does enable one
- synicalx 4y agoYou pay for other services (or devices in the case of pixels) and happen to get the VPN as well. AFAIK there is no way to directly pay for just the VPN. Point being, there's not currently any extra "VPN-only" revenue and no one is entitled to a VPN because they're not actually buying a VPN from Google.
- foota 4y agoThat's semantics. If I buy a TV subscription bundle that includes internet, am I paying for internet? I would argue what matters is the breakdown. I would agree that a vpn is auxiliary to the pixel, but it seems like a pretty core part of the Google One or w/e subscription.
- synicalx 4y agoWith that kind of service you'd be signing a contract that guarantees you internet and cable within whatever level of service you've both agreed on (residential, business etc). You're explicitly being charged for both services from day one, the cost of operating both has been factored in by the vendor. Compare that to Google's VPN, which is nothing more than a value add to existing subscription arrangements that have nothing to do with VPN's. Not to say it isn't a good service - I like it and use it, but I wouldn't be at all surprised to see Google either split it out, jack up their prices to cover it, or just can it altogether.
- syrrim 4y agoIts a service that costs them money. Unless it gains them money somehow, they won't hand it out for free.
- hrrsn 4y agoGoogle One is already a paid service. This is just Google catching up to iCloud Private Relay.
- mark_l_watson 4y ago+1, and I would have given you +2 if I could. Google One 2TB is about $10/month so you are also paying for the VPN. The cheaper Google One plans (I use the cheapest) do not include VPN. I was thinking this morning of updating to Google One 2TB to get the VPN since I just stopped using ProtonMail Premium that included VPN (I decided that Apple Mail with Apple+ family plan met my needs). I forgot that iCloud Private Relay is on, and probably good enough for my needs. Thanks!!
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoInternet’s bandwidth has to literally grow by something like 70% as everything would need two hops if it was to be implemented. Also it would be spammer’s dream, as IP is the number one factor that is used in spam detection.