3 ms·
I am probably the first few if not the first to put JPEG XL on HN's radar. I am definitely not in an JPEG XL Cult. Although I do dislike Google. I am simply a
by ksec 4y ago
I am probably the first few if not the first to put JPEG XL on HN's radar. I am definitely not in an JPEG XL Cult. Although I do dislike Google.
I am simply a supporter of Better Tech. (And I am already omitting WebP hate here. ) And I suspect a lot of us are. And IMO neither WebP nor AVIF are better than JPEG XL.
Had Google actually posted a thorough analysis, as they stated that JPEG XL is not better or even inferior to AVIF, and suggest they decide not to go with it. It would have been fine. ( I may disagree with their take, but at least you can see it from their POV ). Not only did they not do that, they provided the Data with out of date version of JPEG XL [1] and a set of test that does not represent the actual internet usage. Compared to [2], where JPEG XL is surprisingly better when they wont expected.
So if, a) everything JPEG XL released and tested were true, and truly better than AVIF, then b) Why isn't Google supporting the better Image codec?
I am also perfectly fine with Google saying, I dont like it. I hate it because It is not AOM even if JPEG XL is better. Fine. Chrome is Google's browser. Do what ever you want with it.
Just dont ever come out again and say everything you do is better for the Web.
[1] https://storage.googleapis.com/avif-comparison/index.html https://storage.googleapis.com/avif-comparison/index.html
[2] https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1563442356493230080 https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1563442356493230080
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]