4 ms·
Absolutely scummy, and yet another example of something labeled "smart" that's hostile to the user. There needs to be open source firmware for 2D printers too,
by userbinator 4y ago
Absolutely scummy, and yet another example of something labeled "smart" that's hostile to the user.
There needs to be open source firmware for 2D printers too, like there have already been plenty developed for 3D ones. No need to reinvent the whole thing, but just replace the electronics. Presumably the printhead/cartridge interface is still much the same and they haven't gone to the effort of obfuscating/encrypting that yet... https://spritesmods.com/?art=magicbrush https://spritesmods.com/?art=magicbrush
It's unfortunate that printers turned from being based on standard protocols that were documented in the manual they came with (ASCII, ESC/P2, PCL, PostScript, etc.) to these proprietary closed systems. None of the printer manufacturers, including HP, used to be like this.
- alerighi 4y agoPrinters always had proprietary software. Not only that, but the reason why the Free Software movement was started was caused by a printer that Richard Stallman had in its MIT office and that the manufacturer refused to release the source code for its software! > standard protocols You still find printers that support standard protocols, such as IPP (internet printing protocol), that work fine without proprietary drivers with CUPS on Linux. You just have to spend a little more money and avoid consumer stuff, that is Inkjet printers, and go for network laser printers meant to be used in small offices. B/W ones aren't too much expensive, and you can find ones used for not a lot of money, or even free, since companies throw them out, that still work.
- zerocrates 4y agoOne oddity is that, through Linux basically piggybacking on the support printer manufacturers built in to get out-of-the-box printing on Macs and iDevices, the world of Linux printing support is actually really good for newish printers without needing drivers. There are a lot of AirPrint and IPP Everywhere printers out there. I've had good luck in the past, as many have, with Brother's simple laser printers, but was very surprised at the ease of setup on Linux of a new Brother multi-function all-in-one inkjet printer/scanner combo thing: even the scanner worked over the network without a fuss. Night and day compared to my recollections of working with hpijs, hplip, foomatic, even poking around for Brother laser drivers sometimes for ones that didn't talk PCL. But then you have things like this where there's a pointless app forced into the mix to add more friction to that improved story... just because.
- AshamedCaptain 4y ago> You still find printers that support standard protocols, such as IPP (internet printing protocol), It is rare to find a printer these days which doesn't support IPP, even el cheapo inkjet ones. It is required to print from iOS.
- scarface74 4y agoPrinters always needed proprietary drivers to print anything besides ASCII text. Even back in the 8 bit Print Shop days you needed to send separate codes to print graphics. PCL and Postscript are also proprietary and owned by a single vendor.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoFunny that the entire free software ecosystem started because RMS couldn't hack a printer back in the day. It's almost 2023, we still can't hack these things and it keeps getting worse every year. Every single printer thread here on HN I learn about some new DRM nightmare they came up with because fuck consumers. This time it's region locked ink cartridges!
- ethbr0 4y ago> because fuck consumers No, because printers are likely sold below cost, with the profit intended to be recouped through ink sales. If we want open, well-supported printers, we're going to pay a lot more for the hardware.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoOkay. Give me the option to pay.
- seanp2k2 4y agoNot a big enough market for that in the consumer space, so you’ll find what you’re after in a big beige box with a network port made for “SOHO” or mid-size enterprises.
- ethbr0 4y agoExactly. At the risk of beating a dead horse, the HN imagined "technologically-literate, price-insensitive market" doesn't exist at a revenue-relevant scale for most consumer goods.
- danuker 4y agoOR companies are reaching a tacit agreement not to provide "pre-jailbroken" printers anymore. That agreement may be tacit.
- sverhagen 4y agoWait a minute, wasn't I already installing proprietary drivers in the early nineties? And also, those "standard" protocols, weren't those just simpler versions of this proprietary stuff, using the (yes, this part was standardized) pc ports like LPT or RS-something? The fact that they were documented doesn't make it all that much less proprietary, does it? Still, scummy nonetheless.
- imglorp 4y agoYeah and those drivers did all the rendering on PC before sending it to the printer as a bitmap: another way to make the printer cheaper. Good office ones spoke PS and let you offload the PC immediately.
- userbinator 4y agoI'd be sufficiently happy if a printer just accepted writing bmp/gif/jpg/png files to it, because then monsterous proprietary printer drivers wouldn't be necessary. "WinPrinters" were supposed to solve this, since Windows' GDI could do the rasterisation itself (and for non-Windows, similar libraries exist), but clearly that didn't work out. Cheaper, dumber printers with simpler firmware are not a bad thing at all, both for the user and the manufacturer. Unfortunately the latter are more interested in hostile "smart" crap.
- Spooky23 4y ago> It's unfortunate that printers turned from being based on standard protocols that were documented in the manual they came with (ASCII, ESC/P2, PCL, PostScript, etc.) to these proprietary closed systems. None of the printer manufacturers, including HP, used to be like this. The subsidized models were always like this. I used to sell this stuff - the HP/Canon/Epson consumer devices were always subsidized by ink sales and sold below margin. The business devices were always different. I still have a LaserJet 6MP that I bought when I was a retail employee of a computer store in 1997 off the floor. The thing is a tank - it also cost $700 1998 dollars. HP still makes similar devices at similar price points. For my kids, I have a little MFP with instant ink - total cost of $150 for the printer + $180 in ink over 3 years. It’s a good value. Our need for color doesn’t justify a Epson ink tank printer or HP commercial inkjet.