3 ms·
>IOW, heterosexual women are still going to be attracted to traditionally masculine traits. It's almost a tautology - if they weren't, they wouldn't be heterose
by krapp 4y ago
>IOW, heterosexual women are still going to be attracted to traditionally masculine traits. It's almost a tautology - if they weren't, they wouldn't be heterosexual.
Setting aside that "traditional masculinity" is a moving target, plenty of heterosexual women are attracted to non-traditionally masculine traits. Desire isn't merely instinctive. Humans aren't rutting animals hardwired to fuck in the presence of phereomones and sexual display. A person's definition of feminine and masculine absolutely informs, if not defines, who and what they find attractive.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Humans aren't rutting animals hardwired to fuck in the presence of phereomones and sexual display. No one made that claim. > A person's definition of feminine and masculine absolutely informs, if not defines, who and what they find attractive. Nonsense. If that were at all possible, all the "pray the gay away" processes would have worked. It hasn't. What humans find sexually attractive is hardwired. If you want to claim it's a choice, you're going to be arguing with more people than me.
- krapp 4y agoAnd yet there are heterosexual women who remain heterosexual despite not finding traditional masculine traits attractive. They are attracted to men, but are not turned on by big muscles and aggression and alpha male posturing or what have you. And likewise with heterosexual men. That sexual orientation is genetically determined does not presuppose sexual attraction is restricted to a masculine and feminine binary.
- lelanthran 4y ago> They are attracted to men, but are not turned on by big muscles and aggression and alpha male posturing or what have you. Not finding desirable the traits that you think are masculine traits does not mean that they do not find masculine traits desirable. It just means that what you think is the masculine traits, is wrong.
- krapp 4y agoSo your argument is that masculine traits are defined as any traits a heterosexual woman finds attractive in a man, therefore heterosexual women are universally attracted to masculine traits. I guess I can't argue with that.
- lelanthran 4y ago> So your argument is that masculine traits are defined as any traits a heterosexual woman finds attractive in a man, therefore heterosexual women are universally attracted to masculine traits. No, my response was to the original poster of this thread who implied that if we prescribe a new norm for what "masculine" traits are, then women would stop finding the old masculine traits attractive. If it were possible to change what people find sexually attractive all the efforts to "cure" gay people would have worked. My argument is that just because someone has prescribed what masculinity is, doesn't mean that women are going to stop finding the old definition of masculinity more attractive. Sexual attractiveness just doesn't work like that; you can tell people (and even get them to agree) what a man or a women should be, but that doesn't mean that they are going to find examples of that definition attractive.
- Volundr 4y agoTwo things can be true. It can both be true that your sexual desire has an inherit, non-mutable component, while ALSO being partly shaped by your experiences. Just because a homosexual person can't be conditioned to be attracted to the opposite sex does not mean their life experiences can't have some impact on the kind of person they are attracted to. I'd also say that > If it were possible to change what people find sexually attractive all the efforts to "cure" gay people would have worked. is a pretty flawed assumption. Even if we assume sexual attraction is purely based on experience/environment that does not imply that the techniques attempted by the various gay conversion "therapies" would be successful in changing it.
- aidenn0 4y ago> No, my response was to the original poster of this thread who implied that if we prescribe a new norm for what "masculine" traits are, then women would stop finding the old masculine traits attractive. I believe I'm the poster in question and I didn't mean to imply that. What I did mean to imply is that masculine traits that elicit desire are viewed through a cultural lens. If "reliable" or "competent" or "virile" are attractive to women, the ways of signaling that can change over time.