5 ms·
It's also possible that women's expectations of masculine behavior have changed in 30 years...
by aidenn0 4y ago
It's also possible that women's expectations of masculine behavior have changed in 30 years...
- lelanthran 4y ago> It's also possible that women's expectations of masculine behavior have changed in 30 years... That shouldn't change desire - desire is instinctive. All the brain cells in the world aren't going to make you more attracted to someone just because of your definition of feminine/masculine. IOW, heterosexual women are still going to be attracted to traditionally masculine traits. It's almost a tautology - if they weren't, they wouldn't be heterosexual. Same goes for heterosexual men.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> That shouldn't change desire - desire is instinctive Contextual desire triggers are at least partially shaped by experience.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Contextual desire triggers are at least partially shaped by experience. If that were even remotely true, then the arguments about sexual orientation being a choice would be valid. I don't buy either of those arguments, and for pretty much the same reason.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> If that were even remotely true, then the arguments about sexual orientation being a choice No, they wouldn't. “Shaped by experience” is not “choice” and “at least partially” does not mean “definitely specifically as to gender orientation”.
- lelanthran 4y ago> “Shaped by experience” is not “choice” and “at least partially” does not mean “definitely specifically as to gender orientation”. I see where you're going with this, but I still respectfully disagree - gender orientation (whatever the hell that is - do you mean trans people?) is not the same thing as sexual orientation, which is specifically "who you are attracted to", not "the gender you identify as". It's about sex, not gender. And if experience can shape someone's sexual orientation, then the "pray the gay away" type of efforts would have succeeded. A lot of homosexual people in the past did not want to be that way, and yet no experience they had, or sought out, managed to change who they were attracted to. So yeah, the argument "experience can shape your sexual orientation" is, IMNSHO, complete hogwash and at odds with reality as we've seen in the homosexual demographic.
- aidenn0 4y agoI think you are missing the point. I think we both agree that there is a non-conscious process by which humans experience attraction. Let's call this process X. I am a heterosexual male. I therefore am attracted to humans with female biological sex characteristics. If I am walking down the street and see an individual from behind. Lets say they are slightly overweight (increasing waist diameter) and wearing clothing that somewhat masks their hip size. Process X now lacks inputs about typical secondary sex characteristics that can be identified from behind. If it's an individual with short hair and wearing baggy pants, then process X decides it is less likely that the individual is a biological female, but if it is an individual with long hair and a skirt, then process X decides it is more likely that the individual is a biological female. This is an example of contextual desire triggers are at least partially shaped by experience. It can be seen outside of desire too; consider disgust. Bitter flavors tend to trigger disgust in kids. However, take a random new food and mix an emetic with it; watch them react with disgust to that food in the future.
- lelanthran 4y ago> I think you are missing the point. I think it's because your point is orthogonal to my point which was in response to the someone upthread who implied that masculinity as a definition is changing, and that change means that women are finding the new definition attractive. My argument is that it doesn't matter what the prescribed definition of masculinity is, women are going to find attractive what they've always found attractive. Same with men. If it were at all possible that experiences in ones life can change what that individual feels attracted to, efforts to "cure" homosexuality would have been successful.
- krapp 4y ago>IOW, heterosexual women are still going to be attracted to traditionally masculine traits. It's almost a tautology - if they weren't, they wouldn't be heterosexual. Setting aside that "traditional masculinity" is a moving target, plenty of heterosexual women are attracted to non-traditionally masculine traits. Desire isn't merely instinctive. Humans aren't rutting animals hardwired to fuck in the presence of phereomones and sexual display. A person's definition of feminine and masculine absolutely informs, if not defines, who and what they find attractive.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Humans aren't rutting animals hardwired to fuck in the presence of phereomones and sexual display. No one made that claim. > A person's definition of feminine and masculine absolutely informs, if not defines, who and what they find attractive. Nonsense. If that were at all possible, all the "pray the gay away" processes would have worked. It hasn't. What humans find sexually attractive is hardwired. If you want to claim it's a choice, you're going to be arguing with more people than me.
- krapp 4y agoAnd yet there are heterosexual women who remain heterosexual despite not finding traditional masculine traits attractive. They are attracted to men, but are not turned on by big muscles and aggression and alpha male posturing or what have you. And likewise with heterosexual men. That sexual orientation is genetically determined does not presuppose sexual attraction is restricted to a masculine and feminine binary.
- lelanthran 4y ago> They are attracted to men, but are not turned on by big muscles and aggression and alpha male posturing or what have you. Not finding desirable the traits that you think are masculine traits does not mean that they do not find masculine traits desirable. It just means that what you think is the masculine traits, is wrong.
- aidenn0 4y agoThis argument is completely in conflict with my experience; there is nothing inherently feminine about a skirt, long hair, and earrings. Yet, if you dress a man in them, see how desire changes in heterosexual observers of both genders. Another example: facial hair is a secondary sex characteristic for males, and indeed we see that facial hair on women, is relatively universal at reducing attractiveness for heterosexual men. However, the "most masculine" big bushy lumberjack beards are rarely the most attractive, and desirable facial hair across cultures and times has varied greatly.
- lelanthran 4y ago> This argument is completely in conflict with my experience; I don't think it is - I didn't define what I thought were masculine or feminine characteristics. Your counterexamples from your experience (skirts, for example) aren't necessarily feminine characteristics anyway: kilts, long hair and jewellery (earrings and more) have all long been worn by men. I also didn't say that "more" masculine characteristics are more attractive; all I'm saying is that prescribing a new norm for men or women does not in any way mean that hetersexual men or women are going to stop finding the base masculine/feminine traits less desirable.
- EForEndeavour 4y agoI think you're proving aidenn0's point: standards of masculine or feminine attractiveness vary across time, place, and culture, even if the lower-level instinct-based standards remain unchanged. Desire is not just instinctive. To continue the example: a skirt, long hair, and jewelry can conform to either masculine or feminine standards of attractiveness, depending on who, where, and when you ask (and on the specific styles of said skirt and jewelry). Desire is rooted in instinct, but "nurture" clearly plays a huge role in shaping it. I think it's perfectly reasonable to consider the possibility that "women's expectations of masculine behavior have changed in 30 years." The underlying instincts of romantic/sexual desire don't need to change for this to happen.