3 ms·
Ppnas
- PaulHoule 4y agoThere is the situation underlying the ‘replication crisis’, that is, you can get away with fraud. There is also the increasing difficulty of scientific problems driven by the easy problems being already solved which is most acute in physics. Recently there were observations of a quasar that seemed to confirm a theory about how black holes make jets that was proposed in 1980. If you have to wait 40 years to get confirmation of a theory, survival in physics is not a matter of understanding the universe it is a matter of pleasing people. There is also a general ‘dog eat dog’ culture which I think is most clear in the biomedical world where one hears all kinds of stories like ‘A gave a talk about B, person C in the audience rushed to his office and wrote a paper about topic B to get priority’. Someone who does get established in science is like a musical chairs champion or the winner of Survivor and they are really good at the game of survival, to the point that frames such as ‘merit’ and ‘fairness’ don’t really apply. I’m certain that many of the survivors are not morally compromised but some of them crack under the pressure.