5 ms·
There is zero inherent difference between natural vs artificial chemicals. It’s only a question of what effect each chemical has have on the body as “natural”
by Retric 4y ago
There is zero inherent difference between natural vs artificial chemicals. It’s only a question of what effect each chemical has have on the body as “natural” chemicals run the full range from mandatory to lethal in minute quantities.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoThere are some relevant differences regarding byproducts, contaminants, etc. No production process is entirely clean.
- Retric 4y agoThe same is true of refining products from organic sources. You don’t directly get 1lb of table sugar from planting a sugar beet, you need to separate the sugar. At scale this involves adding bleaching agents etc which end up in the final product along with whatever contaminates show up. Run a chemical analysis on several brands of natural sugars and your going to find stuff like sulphur dioxide used as a preservative and trace amounts of industrial lubricants etc.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoYes it is true that any process will have degrees of contamination. I was just contesting that the distribution is “the same”, entirely process/substance dependent!
- Retric 4y agoI agree it’s process dependent but it’s also processor dependent. In the end we can’t say highly refined organic chemicals are strictly better here.
- selectodude 4y ago>No production process is entirely clean. Neither is extraction.
- hilbert42 4y agoBy how much? That's what really matters.
- Retric 4y agoDepends on the supplier not if it’s nominally a natural or artificial chemical.
- hilbert42 4y agoYeah, I wasn't clear, see reply to selectodude.
- selectodude 4y agoI can assure you I would give you an equally unclean garbage product whether I extracted or synthesized.
- hilbert42 4y agoRight. I wasn't really clear, I was referring to the degree of purity not the process or source.
- phyzome 4y agoOne import distinction is that artificial chemicals were not part of the environment our bodies evolved in, whereas some of the natural chemicals were. Furthermore, most of the natural chemicals would be more closely related to other chemicals we did evolve in contact with. The ones that are less novel to our bodies are less likely (in a very general sense!) to cause trouble. For example, cyanide is otherwise lethal but widely present in plants, so our bodies are actually pretty good at dealing with it. So along that axis you could probably lump stevia and aspartame closer together, while sorbitol (which is very much naturally occurring) would be much closer to sucrose.
- Retric 4y agoThe problem showed up because we where concentrating chemicals found in plants in the first place. We aren’t adapted to large quantities of refined sugar and repeating the same process with some other sweeteners runs into the same issue. Evolution adapts to specific environments not every single chemical your ancestors encountered even a minuscule quantity of. I can see why you might find it comforting but it’s really just a just so story. Evolution is really slow and needs significant pressure to result in adaptation, just look at how slowly humanity has been adapting to lactose. Finding an obscure chemical that humans find sweet and then concentrating or manufacturing massive quantities of it isn’t inherently safe even if trace amounts of it are in some plant.
- phyzome 4y agoYou're correct that concentration is important. "The dose makes the poison", as they say. But it's not about being "comforting", it's about having a heuristic to make decisions when you don't have enough hard data. So in general, I try to avoid novel chemicals. It's not a guarantee of anything, but it's good enough for first-pass decision-making.
- Retric 4y agoI have a similar risk aversion for novel chemicals. I simply don’t make an acceptation for organic compounds.
- norwalkbear 4y agoIn an ideal world sure, but in a manufacturing world purity isn't as high people like. My youngest daughter is highly allergic to mold, and has to avoid most sour candy just in case because citric acid is grown in mold based bioreactors.