4 ms·
Reddit has an army of unpaid moderators. Not to mention the Reddit users who upvote and downvote. Also, politicians and other important public figures don't us
by lapcat 4y ago
Reddit has an army of unpaid moderators. Not to mention the Reddit users who upvote and downvote.
Also, politicians and other important public figures don't use Reddit like they use Twitter.
- Victerius 4y ago> Also, politicians and other important public figures don't use Reddit like they use Twitter I think that may change in the future. Many politicians, including prominent ones, have done AMAs. Arnold Schwarzenegger is a semi regular. The Sergeant Major of the US Army is a regular. Rick Astley is a semi regular. Verne Troyer was a regular before he died.
- jeffrallen 4y ago
- ant6n 4y agoHey! No reddit-style comments on HN. Here we have quality discussions, okay?
- riffraff 4y agoBut they don't use it the same way. Twitter allows you to soapbox on any current issue and communicate directly with people. You could in theory do something similar through your own subreddit but then you'd need to manage it, it's not the same thing.
- ohbtvz 4y agoWhat does this have to do with the topic at hand?
- RC_ITR 4y agoGP is making the argument Reddit receives free labor that twitter has to pay for
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SanjayMehta 4y agoAnyone know why those unpaid mods do what they do? It's like a cult.
- ksrm 4y agoextremely hacker news comment
- sekh60 4y agoI am founder and a mod of /r/schizoaffective been doing it for almost ten years now. I made the sub since I felt those with both mood disorder symptoms along side psychosis weren't served well by /r/schizophrenia, /r/depression and /r/bipolar and /bipolar2. I am not a fan of Reddit in a lot of ways, but overall the other mods and I have made a pretty safe place for our community, and we have had relatively little trolling, hopefully it stays that way. Before Reddit I did in person meetups for a couple topics and even in highschool almost twenty years ago I was a big support for a lot of people. Reddit is just a pretty good platform compared to Facebook. The relative anonymity helps a lot in a mental health sub.
- corobo 4y agoWhen I was a free moderator for a thing it was during the time of my life I had little to no control over any aspect of what was happening. I have to assume it's similar for others. Why do this work for free? My only answer to that is it gave me a feeling of being wanted or needed that I was severely lacking at the time.
- ldjb 4y agoA multitude of reasons, I suspect. For instance, they want their community to be civil and not filled with spam. Also, if a subreddit is left unmoderated, it is likely to be shut down by Reddit staff.
- prepend 4y agoHave you ever started an irc channel? For me, it’s kind of like that. I mod some subreddits because I am interested in the topics and want to talk about it and help others talk about it. I spend maybe five minutes a year on it, so it’s more of a responsibility than a labor. As far back as I remember there’s always been bbs moderators. And almost always unpaid. I think Reddit would be worse if mods were paid because then the positions would be more sought after and tried to run as a job. I don’t think Twitter has equivalent moderation.
- yreg 4y agoDo we know how many of those 7k were content moderators? Twitter also had external moderators that are probably not counted in that number.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoQuestion is more why are they paying for moderators when Reddit has proved they’ll do it for free.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoReddit shows that people will sign up to moderate interest-specific forums that they self-select into. Not that people will sign up en masse to generically moderate a large social media platform.
- Anon1096 4y agoThere are a ton of people frothing at the mouth to moderate Twitter for free, it's just that Elon probably doesn't want them too (for good reason!). Hell, many of them regularly @elon even now asking him to remove content they don't like.
- yywwbbn 4y agoI really doubt ‘free’ (i.e. paid by the Chinese/Russian/.. governments) moderation on Twitter would be a good idea
- whywhywhywhy 4y ago>Reddit has an army of unpaid moderators. Smart, Reddit is comfortable with the fact it’s a glorified web forum, Twitter lied to itself that it’s something more.
- bloopernova 4y agoSociety treated twitter as something more, and twitter adapted as it grew. Despite the recent disruptive events, society still treats twitter as a public square. Politicians, celebrities, charities, and governments all make announcements there. So many updates on the russian invasion of Ukraine have been put on twitter but not facebook or instagram. My personal opinion is that twitter is a public square. I don't know what that means legally, because it is an international public square with all the judicial/governmental chaos that implies. I guess an alternative would be to have "twitter is a USA public square" kind of language on the site, but that may well dampen any participation from non-US people.
- whywhywhywhy 4y ago>Society treated twitter as something more No, journalists did. Society at large doesn’t even use Twitter. Their own stats prove this.
- slimebot80 4y agoWell Elon is very, very serious about "journalists" on his site. So this argument gets weird really, really quick.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoI mean I think we can all read between the lines with why he’s interested in it.
- wnevets 4y agoIt got them 44 Billion dollars, they must have been doing something right.
- stiltzkin 4y agoThey do keep astroturfing on Reddit though.