3 ms·
Why is the long term bit crucial? Specifically, what timeframe do you define as "long term", and why do you privilege that timeframe over other timeframes? And
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Why is the long term bit crucial? Specifically, what timeframe do you define as "long term", and why do you privilege that timeframe over other timeframes?
And sometimes exploitation is better than exploration.
Microsoft is a great example of this. Currently MS dumps billions into Bing, a form of exploration. If the shareholders were given a choice, do you think the would choose this? Most likely not - if they wanted to explore search, they would probably dump billions into GOOG. Microsoft shareholders would probably be better off if MS stopped exploring, exploited current revenue streams, and allowed shareholders to invest in businesses with a brighter future.
The working definition should be "maximizing shareholder's time and risk discounted value". After all, $100 now is better than $100 over 10 years (maybe, if we are lucky). When a company focuses on creating long term value, they are gambling with shareholder wealth. They should only do this when the odds are good.
Let's make the law that the managers' options can only be excersized after 10 years. That'll do the trick.
Many companies already do this - a lot of CEO/executive comp is restricted shares.
- lukeschlather 15y ago>Microsoft shareholders would probably be better off if MS stopped exploring, exploited current revenue streams, and allowed shareholders to invest in businesses with a brighter future. That's your judgment. I have to honestly say I'm thankful you're not in charge of Microsoft, because someone trying to compete with Google in the search space is a great thing. (And with Google doing a lot to make Microsoft's core markets vanish, getting into search could save Microsoft's existence in a 10-year timeframe.)
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe two scenarios, supposing that MS's current product line is dead in 10 years, and pretending share prices cost $1 right now): Own MS now. $10 investment yields $20 in profits, all invested in Bing. Net result, in 10 years, you have 20 shares of Bing. Own MS now. $10 investment yields $20 cash in your hands. You buy google. Net result, in 10 years, you own 20 shares of Google. Unless you think Bing is a better investment than Google, you are better off taking the cash and reinvesting in Google. And as an investor, I don't care if MS exists in 10 years. I care whether my portfolio is up or down in 10 years. And I care about liquidity - all else held equal, I'd rather have $1 cash in my hands than $1 cash in MS's hands with me owning shares. If I can invest $10 into MS, take $20 cash out, and have the company die, that's not a bad thing.