7 ms·
This one kinda makes sense to me. Can't really think of any good legitimate use cases for large amounts of cash. Closest I can think of say a bar or something
by Havoc 4y ago
This one kinda makes sense to me. Can't really think of any good legitimate use cases for large amounts of cash.
Closest I can think of say a bar or something similarly cash heavy getting cash and paying suppliers directly. (which is in itself problematic @ tax)
- Hermel 4y agoLike in chess, the moves that you could play matter as much as the moves that you do play. So even if I don't need cash, I still appreciate the possibility of using cash in case my bank of government locks me out of my accounts. For example, the Canadian government froze the accounts of political activists during the Corona crisis. This shocked me. It shows that even countries that are perceived as free and democratic sometimes cannot resist to abuse their power. And the more power we give them, the more likely it is that a politician will abuse his or her power sooner or later.
- shakow 4y ago> Can't really think of any good legitimate use cases for large amounts of cash. Buying a car?
- alkonaut 4y agoI can’t imagine a car dealer who would do anything but laugh if I bought a car north of €10k and suggested I wanted to pay in cash. I’m 100% sure they’d rather not sell the car at all. Same if I privately sold a car that expensive and the buyer showed up with cash. The hassle involved with depositing and withdrawing large amounts of cash due to KYC laws already makes this a no go. And for good reason imo.
- zmgsabst 4y ago“You can’t buy a car without permission” sounds tyrannical to me.
- sofixa 4y agoThen you have no idea what tyrannical means in practical means and are just gasping at straws. It's not a matter of permission, nor is having a car a need or a right. Do you also find needing permission (a driver's license) to drive a car tyrannical?
- zmgsabst 4y agoYou can see Canada’s actions against the truckers or China’s frozen bank accounts for how these laws turn tyrannical in practice.
- alkonaut 4y agoWell there is no law forcing a salesperson to accept cash. So the permission here has little to do with the government. He is no more required to accept my bag of cash as payment than he is my vintage guitar. And while the value might be there, both are a massive hassle for the seller, so they’d simply refuse most likely.
- hayd 4y agoIf that's the case then there's no need for this regulation.
- alkonaut 4y agoI don’t see how that’s related. It’s one thing to regulate who must and must not accept cash. E.g it’s in the interest of society to mandate important functions such as buying food is always possible with cash. The law in the article is about a size limit for cash transactions when cash is accepted. It doesn’t have anything to do with who will or must accept cash. Only that if they do, there is a limit.
- wizeman 4y ago> E.g it’s in the interest of society to mandate important functions such as buying food is always possible with cash. And buying a car is not important? > Only that if they do, there is a limit. And this limit is below the value of most cars. Which is what we were discussing in this thread.
- mr_mitm 4y agoCar dealers are not the only people selling cars. Anybody who owns a car may want to sell it, and using a credit card is not an option for most private sellers. I can see why the 10k limit makes sense, but it would be dishonest to claim that it won't make private car selling a bit more complicated than it was. Escrow services will now probably pop up to facilitate private car sales, but it may be worth it.
- alkonaut 4y agoI’d never ever use cash for a private sale - of anything — either regardless of whether it was $100 or $100k. For a large number like $10k, bank transfers work well. For smaller numbers, instant transfers are cheap and nearly 100% of people use them here (and importantly the same service - so I know I can instantly transfer $2 to anyone at any time for free). When I place an ad to sell a used something for €50 I don’t expect to get cash for it and the seller probably isn’t expecting me to accept cash as payment either. I haven’t used a banknote for probably 10 years now. I haven’t even seen most of the banknotes in circulation here. This isn’t all positive (for privacy and resilience in a crisis), and the fact that I wouldn’t doesn’t change the equally important fact that I want to be able to do it. And that ability is of course in peril here. But it doesn explain the situation quite well wrt to what the real impact of laws like this would be.
- skissane 4y ago> Anybody who owns a car may want to sell it, and using a credit card is not an option for most private sellers Most people use bank transfers for this kind of stuff. The seller gives you their bank account number and you put the money in it. I recently bought a new car from a dealer, and I paid my transferring money to the dealer’s bank account. The dealer took credit card for the initial $1000 deposit but not for the full amount - avoids all those merchant fees on the full amount. Here in Australia, you can now attach your phone number to your bank account (called “PayID”), so the buyer can just go into their Internet banking app, and transfer the money to the seller’s phone number - assuming the seller has set that up. I’ve noticed a lot of people still don’t set it up, often because they just haven’t heard about it
- EthicalSimilar 4y agoI purchased a car that exceeded that value, in cash. The seller actually worked for a bank’s fraud department. I didn’t do it because I store a lot of cash in hand but rather because it was a PITA to move large amounts of money with the bank that I was using. The bank wouldn’t even authorise me to transact more than €10k a day via a bank transfer. It took me a good few hours in the bank - on calls to many departments - just to get access to my money. I’ve since moved to one of the newer challenger banks and it has been the best decision I’ve made.
- Canada 4y ago> can’t imagine a car dealer who would do anything but laugh if I bought a car north of €10k and suggested I wanted to pay in cash. Doesn't sound like how any car salesman, or any commission salesman I've ever met thinks. Car ownership is registered with government anyway, so it's not as if anyone can get away with pretending to be poor and owning a bunch of fancy cars anyway. In my personal experience cash is how used car sales are done between individuals. There is sales tax on used car sales where I'm from. When the sale is agreed the seller and the buyer go to the registry. Say I'm selling you my car for 20k. You don't own the car until I sign ownership to you. I don't get any money until you hand me the cash. So safe thing to do is seller requires buyer to hand cash over and count it in front of the goverment agent. Buyer would prefer seller lie and understate sale price, but seller has no incentive to do that unless buyer gives that cash upfront. Buyer risks seller just saying "nah" and walking away with that cash. So it either requires trust, in which case no scheme the government comes up with can stop us anyway, or one party takes a serious risk, which there is strong disincentive to do. Car has book value government agent knows anyway. Also, goverment exempts tax when seller and buyer are related. Government: "lol, you have trust, our despicable cash grab will not work here anyway so let's not bother" So who cares here? Most big ticket property (eg. Real estate) works like this. Some things like jewlery can slide through, but without receipts is risky crossing borders, which puts a serious damper status/utility of it, and those industries already get higher scruitiny anyway. And anyway, is it worth giving up our liberty over some tax revenue related to stuff like this? So why prevent cash payments? The only purpose it serves it to keep the everyman under total control and open him to even more theft of savings via negative interest rates or transaction fees by financial middlemen. Criminalizing cash is totalatarian in my view.
- lol768 4y ago> I don't get any money until you hand me the cash. Just do a bank transfer to the individual you're buying the car off. Unless you live in a country with incredibly poor payments infrastructure, the funds will be available instantly.
- Canada 4y agoApologies for the late reply. You can't prove that in realtime without a trustee, which is just how things have been done forever. With all due respect, this is how it is in "advanced economies". Where are you personally from where you think anything other than cash provides instant, irreversable, and indusputable settlement in this case?
- djhn 4y agoAny purchase should be possible with legal tender. I will keep withdrawing my income in cash and inconveniencing others with cash transactions for every single purchase, including those exceeding this limit, out of principle. Digital ledgers have proven to be unreliable. Anyone arguing otherwise hasn't witnessed bank runs, withdrawal limits, transaction limits, hyperinflation and war wiping out lifetime savings and destroying people's lives.
- 9dev 4y agoAnd you think a bag full of paper money in your basement will help you once bombs are dropped on your home town? How exactly will that help in war time more than money in your account that you can withdraw once in safety? If you choose to deal with cash exclusively for the sake of it, so be it. But for everyone else, it’s just a less efficient way to move money from account A to account B.
- djhn 4y agoMoney that I have on my person, is always better than money that I cannot access. There is usually at least a short lag between $DISASTER and $ECONOMY_COLLAPSE during which many people are happy to take cash and provide food, shelter and transport. Often you will have a steep inflation curve and rising transaction costs/exchange rates, but at least you are in control of the money that you have in your pocket. The same cannot be said about digital money. Even though in theory you have a larger pool of places where you could spend it, money that is in your account isn't guaranteed to be accessible. Banks' infrastructure may be down, whether due to $DISASTER itself or corporate/political decision. The banks may impose withdrawal limits or a complete restriction on withdrawals and transactions. Online transactions may fail at any point in the acquirer-issuer-processor chain. ATM:s are likely to be empty. Online transactions may be reversed. Even when you manage to "lock in" exchange rate X just before a currency's collapse in value, the merchant can and will cancel your order, make up excuses, and refund you the nominal value at the old exchange rate.
- samtho 4y ago> Can't really think of any good legitimate use cases for large amounts of cash. Affluent people tend to diversify where they keep their money. They have a few different checking accounts, savings/money-market accounts, brokerage accounts, assets, petty cash, and probably some other things. If you do not have the level of wealth that gives you the flexibility to keep large sums of money in a relatively inaccessible place (e.g. a brokerage account that might take 1-3 days to liquidate and another day to do a bank transfer), you might opt to keep a few thousand in cash in case something happens with your bank, such as your account being frozen or just drained due to fraudulent activity. It’s always prudent to keep reserves in diversified locations.
- zmgsabst 4y agoI want to be able to legally receive my salary as cash without special permission; eg, a customer paying me for a project. This law prohibits paying me for a month in cash.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIf you make more than 10k euro in a month, that is.
- kvdveer 4y agoThis law prohibits you from doing that without reporting it. You'd have report that anyway, when filing your taxes, so apart from some extra admin work, that's not much of an extra hurdle, assuming it honest money. If you receive your €10k as payment for a shipment of cocaine, you probably don't want to report it, so then you'll enter the territories of fiscal crime.
- kgwgk 4y agoThe only exceptions would be: (a) payments between persons who are not acting in a professional function; (b) payments or deposits made at the premises of credit institutions, electronic money institutions and payment institutions. [...]; (c) central banks when performing their tasks. It's not that you would have to report it - you just cannot do it.
- Canada 4y agoI want to be able to pay for at least a year of rent without relying on a bank. I want to be able to pay for as much as possible without leaving any record with a third party if I don't want to. I also want to be able to take all of my money out of the bank and keep it for myself, and give it to whoever I want, whenever I want, without having anyone's permission to do so, or reporting that I have done so to anyone. Why is that illegitimate?
- endgame 4y agoExtremely appropriate username.
- Teandw 4y agoIt's quite simple really. Because the vast majority of people that want to do those things, are wanting to get away with doing bad things and/or not paying their way correctly in society. You may be a rare outlier but there has to be precautions.
- Canada 4y agoThis is an honest answer. Thanks for giving me the benefit of the doubt. I don't want to live in the same society as you, or be a part of one where people who share your opinion are the majority who get to make the rules.
- vageli 4y agoAnd someone decided once to put an explosive in their shoe, and now we all have to take our shoes off at the airport. At this rate, our future is looking extremely restricted.
- _-david-_ 4y agoHere is an easy one. Paying for food when there are power outages.
- ilyt 4y ago10k for food ?
- _-david-_ 4y agoThe person I was responding to said large sums, not 10k specifically. This bill/rule thing allows member states to have an amount lower than 10k. If there are prolonged power outages or some sort of disaster, prices will increase for food. Don't forget with the amount of inflation we have also increases prices for food. Some people like to buy canned food or other food that lasts in bulk to get lower prices.
- ilyt 4y agoThey probably meant sum in the title...