4 ms·
There was a time in America where if you committed fraud, no matter how "technically legal", you would be lynched. Until dead. And juries would acquit your murd
by nl 15y ago
There was a time in America where if you committed fraud, no matter how "technically legal", you would be lynched. Until dead. And juries would acquit your murderer.
Citation needed.
Or more to the point - when exactly do you think think period was?
For example, in 1804 the sitting vice president (Burr) was accused (probably correctly) of corrupt dealings. He challenged his accuser to an (illegal) pistol duel and killed him[1]. Burr was charged with murder, but the charges were dropped and Burr continued his political career "out west". This was hardly an isolated incident - US history is full of similar examples - not exactly the honourable behaviour you seem to believe was the norm.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burr-Hamilton_duel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burr-Hamilton_duel
- cwp 15y agoTwo hundred years later, the sitting vice president (Cheney) was accused[1] (probably correctly) of corrupt dealings. He just ignored his accusers and nothing came of it. Now, I realize you were responding to the statement about lynching, but it's worth noting that challenging someone to a duel is what you do when your honor has been questioned. In fact, the Wikipedia page on "Honour" includes an illustration of the Burr-Hamilton duel, with the caption, "Alexander Hamilton defends his honour by accepting Aaron Burr's challenge." It also describes honour as deriving from "perceived virtuous conduct and personal integrity." It would seem that honour really was a more important thing two hundred years ago than it is today. [1] http://www.google.ca/search?q=Cheney+corrupt+dealings&hl=en&biw=1434&bih=1323&sa=X&ei=abf4To-FIeOuiQKRz7yyDg&ved=0CAwQpwUoBg&source=lnt&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A2004-1-1%2Ccd_max%3A2004-12-31&tbm= http://www.google.ca/search?q=Cheney+corrupt+dealings&hl...
- mikeash 15y agoI don't think that murdering your rightful accuser and getting away with it is really what most people mean when they say "honor" these days. Maybe honor did used to be more important, but it's not the same concept, only the same word.
- forensic 15y agoIt's more accountability than what Dick Cheney faced. The point is that even under primitive social codes like the honour system, public officials faced more accountability than they do now. There is no accountability left whatsoever in ANY social leaders: not business leaders, not industry leaders, not political leaders, not military leaders, not scientific leaders, not legal leaders. ZERO personal accountability. They can be as corrupt as they want, they can fuck it up as bad as they like, but there are absolutely no consequences to them. This is what has changed. At least in the 1800s you could be challenged to a duel when you engaged in corruption. At least in the 1800s robber barons had to protect themselves from vigilante justice.
- mikeash 15y agoPerson A ignores his accuser. Person B murders his accuser and goes on with life. How exactly is B more accountability? As far as I know, Dick Cheney hasn't murdered any of his accusers.
- forensic 15y agoIt's not murder it's a duel. Big difference. Both duellists put their lives on the line. How many people in America right now would be willing to have a duel with Cheney? Hundreds if not thousands. That says something meaningful about his role.
- mikeash 15y agoI don't really see why a duel isn't a murder. Plenty of murderers put their lives at risk to kill. Just because the other guy agreed to it doesn't make it not a murder. I guarantee you that if I challenged somebody to a duel today and ended up killing him that I would go to jail for murder, and rightly so.
- cwp 15y agoI'm not saying Burr was honourable. I'm saying he cared about being perceived as honourable. As did Hamilton, or he wouldn't have accepted the challenge. Cheney, in contrast, doesn't give a damn what people think, as long as Halliburton keeps getting government contracts. The point is not that people were more virtuous in the past. It's that virtue, or at least the perception of virtue, was considered important in the past, much more so than today.