3 ms·
> I said "From a tax perspective" in a parenthetical in my very first comment, to show an example of how, legally, direction donations and pass-through donation
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> I said "From a tax perspective" in a parenthetical in my very first comment, to show an example of how, legally, direction donations and pass-through donations are different
You don't seem to understand how they're different.
The difference is that in one case, the customer is entitled to a tax deduction, and in the other case, they aren't. That is a choice the store makes. But it doesn't affect the store, or the charity. There is a difference, from a tax perspective, and that difference applies only to the customer.
Going back to my earlier example, we see that the store must pay taxes on $30 of revenue in every scenario, while the customer always has to pay income tax on $30 of income, but may or may not have to pay income tax on the additional $5.
That is the only legal difference. How do you think it applies to this lawsuit?
After that, you're arguing about whether CVS has "really" donated any money to the ADA. As I have repeatedly pointed out, in every parallel scenario, the answer is unambiguously yes. Salesmen "really" bring in revenue when they haven't personally purchased anything. Politicians "really" bring in revenue when they haven't personally donated anything. Fundraisers "really" bring in revenue when they haven't personally donated anything. Logistical improvements "really" bring in profit even though that comes in the form of lowered costs and revenues don't increase at all.
> The ADA gets not a single penny more money from each donation if CVS only hands over the $10 million it had already pledged of its own money.
This is clearly untrue; see my sidethread example of a structured donation in which a pledge of $15 million in matched donations raises $25 million in match-seeking donations. You really believe CVS customers were tracking the total amount of donations and stopped when it hit $10 million?