2 ms·
The permissions granularity is a problem, but I think the bigger problem is that the designs for these permissions banners need to change to adapt to the post-G
by lolinder 4y ago
The permissions granularity is a problem, but I think the bigger problem is that the designs for these permissions banners need to change to adapt to the post-GDPR world of the cookie banner.
Users on the web today have pop-up fatigue like we've never seen before. If you have uBlock or similar set to block the banners, you may not realize just how bad most users have it. When the average internet user sees a big popup window asking for their consent and there's a big green button at the bottom, at this point they're conditioned to immediately go to the bottom and click on the big green button to get back to what they were doing.
OAuth consent modals look like a cookie banner. There's a big title saying "X would like permission to", followed by a list of permissions they want, followed by a "Proceed" and "Cancel" button. GitHub's is better than most in that the text on the big green proceed button is explicit, but by the time the user's eyes rest on that button it's too late, they're already tuned out and ready to get to the content they're trying to access.
I'm not sure what the solution is, but we have to change the design of those banners. It's not OAuth's fault that the cookie banner created this problem, but we can't stubbornly insist on retaining the same design just because OAuth was there first.