5 ms·
> Electric cars certainly reduce particulate emissions a lot further, but tire and break wear has become a significant part of particulate emissions. Doesn't r
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> Electric cars certainly reduce particulate emissions a lot further, but tire and break wear has become a significant part of particulate emissions.
Doesn't regenerative braking reduce both tire and brake wear?
- avelis 4y agoBrake wear for sure.
- ihattendorf 4y agoBrake yes, I don't see how it would help tire wear (assuming you slow down at the same speed). Electric cars typically have higher tire wear because of the increased weight + typically higher torque/acceleration.
- ceejayoz 4y agohttps://www.nokiantyres.com/company/news-article/there-is-a-common-misconception-related-to-electric-cars-in-reality-tires-will-last-for-a-long-time/ https://www.nokiantyres.com/company/news-article/there-is-a-... > Tires on a modern electric car will wear down much slower than in a car with a traditional internal combustion engine. This is due to good traction control. The driver assist systems reduce slipping by utilizing the electric motor's rapid power adjustment. This system is much quicker than in ICE vehicles, where it is based on braking and limiting engine RPM, Liukkula says. I dunno if anyone's done a good scientific study on this.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoIn addition to this, people are aware of the existence of regenerative braking, and that it works better when decelerating less aggressively, so they do. Which puts less wear on the tires.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoSounds like shit to me. How much time do you spend spinning your tyres and braking so hard you skid?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 4y agoYou don't have to fully skid the thing to see a benefit from better control over the breaking process. From the skid marks I've seen on the highway, rare skids seem to pull off a significant amount of rubber in one incident.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe tires cannot generate any longitudinal acceleration with zero slippage. This slippage is what causes wear. (As a driver, though you perceive there to be zero slippage without wheelspin or sliding the tires, there is slippage between the road and tire anytime the tire is exerting a longitudinal force on roadway.)
- smachiz 4y agoThis was, in my experience, not true. Ask most Tesla owners as well. The heavier car + much better acceleration created more tire wear than any improvements to traction control from faster power response (though I'm not sure intrinsically why that would reduce wear - ICE cars can apply brakes to a slipping tire just as well as an EV, and instant torque doesn't feel like it would do anything positive for tire wear). Fitting lower rolling resistance tires on ICE cars would provide any of the same benefits that EVs receive.
- r00fus 4y agoTesla != EV. My Ford Focus EV, while having annoyingly skinny tires have lasted 60k mi and 5+ years. It's no slouch and I'm a lead-foot. That Tesla is pushing run-flats may be why they wear out so ridiculously fast.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> This was, in my experience, not true. Ask most Tesla owners as well. I suspect "ludicrous mode" will be less likely in semis. Truckers have a pretty good incentive to maximize cost savings; they don't need crazy acceleration like a high-end consumer sedan might want.
- eagsalazar2 4y agoPart of the issue is that modern run-flat tires have stupidly low lifespans, like 20K miles. I have a Tesla and opted for non-run-flats with my latest change and I don't think my tires wear any faster than other cars I've had.
- chris222 4y agoThe tires my Tesla came with lasted only about 20,000 miles. I replaced them with better tires and those are not even close to wearing out after 30,000 additional miles.
- sliken 4y agoWhich tires did you switch to?
- dahfizz 4y agoSpinning the tires will obviously accelerate wear, but I don't think that's the source of most of the tire wear we see in the wild. Spinning the tires isn't all that common, but tires still wear down.
- sliken 4y agoSure, it helps. However not only are EVs heavier, but there's a significant incentive to use narrow tires (for the weight) to increase efficiency and range. As a result, while not skidding, it's easy to accelerate, brake, or decelerate enough to scrub the tires hard enough to wear quickly. It's pretty well known that Teslas are hard on tires. One benefit is I rarely use brakes instead of regenerative braking. Having AWD does seem to help on that front.
- rob74 4y agoAnecdotal evidence: I regularly manage to (unintentionally) spin the wheels in a petrol car, but I have never managed to do it in an electric car yet, despite trying out the full acceleration. So while the torque is undeniably greater, apparently the motor management control is also better, so it can deliver maximum acceleration without increased tire wear - at least in the electric cars I have been driving (mostly BMW i3).
- comte7092 4y agoBrakes certainly, but all motion still needs to be stopped through friction against the ground. EVs are significantly heavier for the time being, so if anything they have greater wear on tires all else equal.
- malfist 4y agoIs that true though? Energy has to go somewhere, but if you store a large part of that energy into batteries, doesn't that take away from what you have to expend on friction with the road? After all, energy can't be created or destroyed. So if you're storing it in batteries, it's coming out of your forward momentum.
- SamBam 4y agoEnergy that would normally have been lost in heating up/destroying the brake pads instead goes into the battery, of course. But I don't see why this alone would affect the tire tread.
- comte7092 4y agoYou aren’t regaining 100% of the kinetic energy so a significant part has to be lost somewhere else. Realistically regenerative braking is recouping energy that would be lost as heat when the friction brakes act on the wheels. However it would not stop a vehicle on a zero friction surface, as a simple example, so no it doesn’t take away from the friction heat losses on the road.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Is that true though? 100%. Brakes do not stop a car, tires do. Brakes just manage the energy. Putting it back into a battery so it can be used to accelerate again is great, but it's still the tires stopping the car.
- mlindner 4y ago
- ewgoforth 4y agoBrake wear yes, but the resistance to forward motion still has to be transferred via that tires.
- malfist 4y agoQuick google says regenerative breaking has ~65% efficiency at energy recovery, but that includes the 10-20% lost when converting stored energy back into kinetic energy. So it sounds like regenerative breaking would covert ~75%-85% of kinetic energy into stored chemical energy. I'd expect to see similar reduction in tire and brake wear as well, maybe even more it probably depends on how break dust is generated, if it has a curve where more is generated with greater breaking force applied, by dropping the force on a break pad to 15% of it's previous value we might see an even greater reduction. This is all speculation though, I am not a physicist.
- qqtt 4y agoThe energy efficiency of turning regenerative braking into energy isn’t really related to how regenerative braking can fully stop a vehicle without using the brake pads. Even if the regenerative braking energy efficiency were 1% - if it fully stops the car without using a brake pad that entire wear & tear (& dust) goes away.
- vagrantJin 4y agoThanks for pointing this out. Many arguments here are about regenerative braking - which does not the address the issue of tire wear.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoAbsolutely. I have an EV that has an "aggressive regenerative braking" setting where pulling your foot off the accelerator slows the car considerably. In that setting I almost never touch the brake.
- jeffbee 4y agoPutting your foot on the brake pedal has almost nothing to do with whether the friction brake is engaged in an EV or hybrid. A computer decides when and how much to pressurize the friction brakes.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThat's true, but my point is that, at least in my car, taking your foot off of the accelerator does not ever engage the friction brakes, and when I drive it's nearly 100% "one pedal driving". What you're saying, that when you do press the brakes that a computer decides how much to apply regen vs friction, is true, but again, my point is that I don't touch the brakes.
- sliken 4y agoDepends on the car, the Tesla default setting is not use brakes when you life the throttle or use regeneration when you hit the brake. This lets you control how you slow down, which makes it easier to be nearly 100% regenerated.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- giardini 4y agoRegenerative braking will reduce brake pad wear since part of the power otherwise dissipated as braking friction between pad and disc/drum is captured by the motor/generator, converted to electrical power and stored. Tire wear should be unaffected provided the e-car has a "freewheeling" feature whereby braking is not applied unless the driver hits a brake pedal. If the e-car is set to always run in a regenerative braking mode (brake goes on if driver eases off the "gas" pedal) then the braking will actually increase tire wear.