4 ms·
I think this study is important because it states very plainly that stress is bad for you, and there's no such thing as "good stress." Edit: Wow you all really
by Spivak 4y ago
I think this study is important because it states very plainly that stress is bad for you, and there's no such thing as "good stress."
Edit: Wow you all really like your stress huh?
- rco8786 4y agoI did not see anything at all in this study that said either of those things. It says "volatile pay is stressful in a bad way" but makes no claim about stress as a whole?
- TillE 4y agoHigh blood pressure is bad.
- cinntaile 4y agoThe thing that is common among all those low- and highpaying jobs with volatile pay is that those are jobs where you have to deal with constant stress.
- Spivak 4y agoYes and it's able to immediately explain away "oh well they're low income so that's the cause of their health issues." Nope, the same thing happens to millionaires, it's the stress.
- coldtea 4y agoIt says "volatile pay is stressful and affects health badly". Not about "stress in a bad way" as opposed to some "good stress".
- winReInstall 4y agoThere is stress that ends another stressor. If you are permant stressing about your job, your life your mortage and you boulder for the first time, you might eperience mortal fear, from falling. Which makes the other stressors less substantial, thus "deactivating" or back-queuing them. After the fear for your life, the stress bodily reflex does not return usually in full force. You relax. One good "short" stress ended alot of bad stress. There is no good stressor that is permanent. PS: Thanks to the prof at college teaching us about this. Stress is pure poison, inlcuding flooding your body with cortisols and supressing disease symptoms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cortisol#Immune_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cortisol#Immune_response Resulting in the ilusion, that stress keeps you healthy. Meanwhile disease eats you alive and re-appears once you are a wreck. If you regularly experience stress episodes for months and years, you might as well be a living corpse.
- Spivak 4y agoI don't really think this is a disagreement. "Sometimes you have to do something that's bad for you to keep something worse from happening." That's just called harm reduction. The stress is still bad but short term stress that ends long term stress can be a good trade when you don't have any other option.
- winReInstall 4y agoYes, the correct response would be a behavioural adjusting of "not giving a damn" but our economic system discourages this, encouraging instead a play pretend of "unstressed" or meditate it away, aka learn to control your stress response system. Or we could mass give out calming substances like weed or alcohol, but now we get to were we actually categorize permanent stress correctly. Its a mass applied substance problem, used to extract value from people.
- adamrezich 4y ago> and there's no such thing as "good stress." this is not true though. I have a close friend who comes from a very wealthy family, to the point where, if he wants to, he doesn't have to work another day in his life. it took him something like eight years to get a four-year degree. he's struggled a lot with motivation over the years, and I became increasingly empathetic toward his situation the more I talked to him about it. it's really hard to find motivation to do stuff, even stuff you tell yourself you want to do, if it takes effort, and if there's no proverbial "fire lit under your ass" to get you to actually do something ("if I don't get another job before the end of next month, I won't have enough money to pay rent", etc.). I've done some of my best creative work while under immense stress. great things rarely, if ever, get created in zero-stress environments. this idea that stress is always objectively bad is a very first-world way of thinking.
- ls15 4y agoRegardless of creative or academic output, how is your friend feeling health-wise?
- adamrezich 4y agoafter a few dark months of largely staying at home and watching youtube all day, he's doing great now, working at a game development collective sort of thing making stuff with other creative people. I'm actually a bit jealous of his situation now, because I had to leave that career behind, but I'm really happy that he got out of the depression-hole ("bad stress") and is now actively working with other people directly (in-person, in an office!) making cool stuff and vibing with other creative minds, even despite having deadlines to deal with ("good stress"). he seems happier than he's been in years and I'm glad things have ended up working out well for him after a period of darkness (something which pretty much happened to me just a couple years ago, too).
- Spivak 4y agoYour two examples are harm reduction, not of "good stress." In both cases the actual stress is still bad for you. If your friend had motivation that was not based on imminent danger that would be better. If you could do creative work while not under stress that would be better. Stress is objectively bad for your health. That's a different statement from "in certain cases I need to compromise my heath for a greater good."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]