3 ms·
And nothing of value was lost. If you want ad-free services, you can absolutely afford to chip in some money to the service provider, which keeps things above-
by zozbot234 4y ago
And nothing of value was lost. If you want ad-free services, you can absolutely afford to chip in some money to the service provider, which keeps things above-board and legit. Don't be a darn cheapskate.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoA bit too judgemental. Please point us towards an ad-free paying service that doesn't simultaneously track your profile/views/clicks? The problem at the moment is that there is no multimedia host that actually just hosts, they all track unique customer habits chasing that recommendation engine big data gravy train. Also reminder that most copyright infringement is from non-industrialized nations where people indeed cannot afford to 'chip in some money to the service provider'.
- kuschku 4y agoThe data this company has put behind a paywall is the european weather model, which was developed with tax payer money, is run with tax payer money, and the data of which is almost entirely available for free to anyone that wants to access the data. Companies like the one that posted this take down notice actually sued (!) the national weather services in a few EU countries to prevent national weather services from publishing weather data to consumers for free, arguing that the weather service should run free APIs, but these companies should be able to build ad and subscription supported apps using these free APIs. https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/20200312_bgh_urteil_news.html https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/2020... All these companies did was build a fence around it and charge a fee. How does that even reach the necessary threshold of originality for copyright?
- that_guy_iain 4y agoBecause they built the app... They aren't copyrighting the data. They're copyrighting their app.
- kuschku 4y agoAn app that's a thin wrapper around public data. Apps like this have sued the public weather services in multiple EU countries to take down the official apps, e.g., https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/20200312_bgh_urteil_news.html https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/2020... Fuck private weather apps.
- that_guy_iain 4y ago> Apps like this have sued the public weather services in multiple EU countries to take down the official apps, e.g., https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/2020 https://www.dwd.de/DE/presse/pressemitteilungen/DE/2020/2020... Very important note here. The DWD was found by the highest court in Germany to be acting illegally.
- kuschku 4y agoI'm arguing that the law itself is wrong here. I don't see any value in dozens of different, bad, private apps rehashing the same weather report data. That the law values the rights of those companies to rent-seek higher than the right of citizens to be informed is extremely dangerous. The same reasoning could be applied to news, laws, or even firefighting. Some services should just be provided by the state and not by private companies.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoHow about no. Find another business model or go bankrupt. This rent seeking has to end.
- zozbot234 4y agoAnother business model, as in "just give sh*t away for free, without even advertisements to pay for it"? That's not going to be very successful.
- kuschku 4y agoYou can't make a business out of everything. By the same reasoning you could argue for banning breathing because it prevents a potential canned-air market.
- teh64 4y agoBecause it costs money to provide services? You could not argue that with the same reasoning, because there is no labor involved for air to exist. However services need to be run by people using hardware created by other people, all of whom need to eat, which is only possible with money.
- kuschku 4y agoWhy? This service could just as well be provided by the national weather service directly. Why do we need a dozen companies rehashing and reselling the same public dataset?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI dunno. Make a patreon or something. Do it for love. Don't do it at all. If you send me ads, I'll delete them. If you send me DRM'd data, I'll get rid of it. These are not acceptable business models.
- teh64 4y ago
- sensanaty 4y agoOr I can continue to not pay for them to track every single microscopic interaction I ever have with any of their systems :)
- underlines 4y agoI first had internet access in 1998 as a 12 year old without any money. It became a habit to find anything for free: mp3's on metager's "index of" searches, cracks on astalavista.box.sk, movies on IRC bots, 0 day software and games from scene FTPs, later on the whole P2P stuff like gnutella, DC++, torrent etc. and in the mid 00's the move to shared hosters. The fact that I was 12 and didn't get pocket money made me find all my stuff for free and it sticked to this day, except it's either waaaaaaay more convenient to pay a few bucks, or impossible to get otherwise. So over the years I stopped with my 500GB MP3/AAC/FLAC music collection and moved to Spotify (Which I still hate, because there's always indie stuff that isn't available PLUS stuff they remove, without informing me!). I also stopped pirating movies for some time because of Netflix, but after the democratization of streaming services and the return to walled off exclusives on multiple platforms, I simply went back to torrent streaming. Software is another thing I ALWAYS pirate, the only exception if I use it professionally or make money in any other form by using it. I am not proud of this, but saving a few bucks seems to be more important to me when I can. This is probably, because it has been ingrained into my brain for years as a child. I worked in the Digital Marketing business for 10 years (AdTech and MarTech) especially working in Analytics and Data Collection and I never saw ads. Used modified youtube clients for years, uBLock Origin on Desktop AND mobile. Seeing the unfiltered web on friend's devices makes me wonder how they can even brows the web...
- rolenthedeep 4y agoBlocking ads on YouTube doesn't affect anyone's bottom line except Google. Creators on YouTube only receive a small percentage of YouTube ad revinue, and most don't count it as stable income because YouTube loves to demonitize videos for no reason and you have almost no recourse once it does. That's why every video now has embedded ads, which is something entirely different because it's controlled by and paid to the creator directly. I don't mind giving creators money, and I'm fortunate enough that I can afford to subscribe to several of them every month. Because they deserve my money, not Google.