3 ms·
I was disappointed when Postscript was initially released, as they were at pains to port the constraints of paper to the computer, which I considered (and still
by gumby 4y ago
I was disappointed when Postscript was initially released, as they were at pains to port the constraints of paper to the computer, which I considered (and still consider) a gross step backwards. Display postscript (Sun and NeXT mostly) was an improvement but documents were still stuck in a paperish mode. Few PDF are truly editable.
This was made much worse when displays migrated from portait by default to landscape by default.
Even today my heart sinks when I see that I've been given a pdf
- User23 4y agoPostscript was solving the problem of producing nice proofs for photo transfer. Complaining about how it's not a great display protocol on modern flatscreens isn't missing the point, it's not even realizing there is a point to be missed.
- gumby 4y agoThat’s not how it was marketed. I used the Dover and its postscript predecessor (I can’t remember the name) so I’m familiar with the page description languages described in the article (I was at PARC for a while). PDF was supposed to go beyond that, and its parametric model was a conceptual win…then mostly constrained as a semantic-free rendering system.
- massysett 4y agoAs bad as a PDF is, it's even worse to get a Word document. Now, imagine saving that Word document and trying to open it twenty years from now.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoHmm, yes and no. If you want to be able to edit more than a single word or two, I'd rather have the Word doc, it can at least handle wrapping text, widow control etc. (even if the format is a moving target and even MS can't seem to always handle it... so yes, in 20yr you'll need to do your edits via DOSBox). If you only need to read it, PDF wins certainly.
- kondro 4y agoGiven I can still open and edit Word documents created 30 years ago I don't think that will be as much a problem as you suggest.
- Stratoscope 4y agoThe portrait format of most PDFs is one of the reasons I always insist on having a portrait mode monitor. My current setup uses three 4K displays: my ThinkPad P1's built-in display plus two 24" 4K monitors (currently LG, but I've also used Dell). One of the 24" monitors is above the ThinkPad display, in landscape mode with the left edges aligned. (Actually the monitor's left edge is just a pinch to the left of the ThinkPad display's, so they look aligned when I'm using them.) The other 24" monitor is to the left of these, in portrait mode. The bottom edge is about 3/4" above the desk, allowing room for cables to go underneath it. The portrait mode display is perfect for reading PDF files, and also great for HTML documentation, long text files, etc. Note that 27" monitors would be less ideal for this configuration. The top of the portrait mode 27" display is too high up and would cause neck strain. All three displays are the same distance from my eyes, about 20", and I wear single-vision prescription glasses adjusted for that distance. The ThinkPad display scaling is set to 300%, and the 24" displays at 200%. It is a pretty great setup.
- dylan604 4y ago>This was made much worse when displays migrated from portait by default to landscape by default. When were displays ever portrait by default? I'm only familiar with resolutions wider than tall. The oldest I've used were the amber/green monochrome CRTs. I honestly don't know the dimensions of those but they were back when 80chars per line (or whatever the count) limits existed. But even then, it always seemed to me to be more chars across than rows down.
- gumby 4y agoCharacter terminals like the AAA were portrait — 80x48, yes, but characters were taller than wide. But I was thinking if bitmapped displays since we were talking about PDF: the Alto was the first such, and was bitmapped, as were CADRs, BLIT, PERQ etc…
- eschaton 4y agoThe early workstations like the Alto, PERQ, and CADR were portrait by default, and used specialized CRTs. Personal computers tended to use 4:3 displays because they started out with either terminals (which used television CRTs) or by being plugged into literal televisions. Workstations went to two-page displays a decade and change before even 1024×768 was widespread for personal computers outside ones used as workstations (e.g. very high end PCs and Macs used for CAD, page layout, etc.).
- smackeyacky 4y agoIt is a shame. My first encounter with PostScript was getting a TeX / LaTeX post processor to output PostScript to the universities newly purchased LaserWriter (so much CamelCase ha ha). When the Sun rep brought us a tape with NeWS to load up to our Sun Workstations we were quite excited, but it was so slow it was nearly unuseable. We scurried back to SunView pretty quickly. edit: can't remember if it was dvi2ps or dvips, but we ended up having to hack it to be able to embed graphics because LaTeX at the time either couldn't do that or could do it but dvi2ps didn't understand it. Fun times.
- Maursault 4y ago> Few PDF are truly editable. You would say the same thing if you were trying to edit a Word document in a browser and you'd never seen a word processor. All PDF can be edited like any other electronic document, you just need the right tools. There are a bazillion PDF editors now and Google sucks worse every day, but I learned to edit PDF with PitStop Pro. I could edit a PDF as though working with QuarkXPress on a Quark document or working with Adobe InDesign on an InDesign document. Once you have access to internals of a PDF and tools to manipulate the objects and type, editing PDF is no big deal. Few locks can be truly opened if you don't have a key (or a pick, or a hammer, etc.).