3 ms·
It's easy to blame the popular meme of "short sighted management", but they aren't necessarily as short sighted as you think. Often management gets rid of the
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
It's easy to blame the popular meme of "short sighted management", but they aren't necessarily as short sighted as you think.
Often management gets rid of the old guard because the old guard actively prevents the business from improving it's processes. I know someone (maybe multiple people) who works at a large financial institution. A particular department there is running on ancient systems using ancient processes, most of which can and should be properly outsourced to $BIGVENDOR. The fed agrees, and is constantly hitting them with MRIA's (Matters Requiring Immediate Attention).
But right now there are many managers of 50-100 employees who will become redundant when 49 of their employees are replaced by a few servers in NJ. These people tend to passive aggressively slow down the replacement, hoping to delay it until they retire. There are other people who have stable jobs, based not so much on competence as the fact that they hold lots of institutional memory. They don't want to help build a system that will make their knowledge obsolete.
When management fires these people, it doesn't do so because it doesn't understand their value. It does so because they are actively hindering the company from moving forward.
Sometimes this process fails as you describe. But when properly managed, this process results in a streamlined department half the size it was before, processes properly documented, everything automated, where people are fighting to improve efficiency from 99.7% to 99.9%.
- georgieporgie 15y agoI downvoted you for framing someone's observation as a generalization, and then trying to argue about it.
- lkrubner 15y agoI upvoted you because you explained your downvote. Anonymous voting is what I like least about Hacker News. I prefer that people vote publicly. On my own site, I'm about to start offering actual cash (very small amounts, mere pennies) to people who explain their votes.
- Mz 15y agoI would be interested in learning how that experiment goes. Social hacking fascinates me and at one time I spent quite a lot of time performing "private" experiments/tests with regards to influencing forums/email lists. I would be especially interested in seeing a write up done beforehand as to your logic/reasons for doing it and what you hope to achieve and then a write up afterwards to see what the actual results were. The information is a lot less valuable/interesting to me if there is no beforehand piece of it, put in writing before actual implementation. However, it probably should not be published until you get results, just written down. Publishing it could contaminate the data as it could influence the outcome and make it impossible to tell if the money or the article was driving change. Best of luck.
- aangjie 15y ago+1 to documenting the hypothesis+ prediction and the results.. I would love to see that too.. yep.. am ok with not publishing the hypothesis first too..
- lkrubner 15y agoThat is a great idea. And I understand the need to keep the prediction secret till later. I just wrote this up and sent it to you as an email. We will see how things work out over the long term.