3 ms·
"and it shows how poor entire states become when the soil is poor (which I suppose is not unlike the American midwest!)" I'm not sure this is the reason the mi
by giantg2 4y ago
"and it shows how poor entire states become when the soil is poor (which I suppose is not unlike the American midwest!)"
I'm not sure this is the reason the midwest is poor. In relation to farming, the size of land needed to make a good living has continually increased largely due to overhead costs increasing (insurances, general cost of living, and equipment). You have a lot of farms that try to hold on and are eventually consumed by corporate farms. Then factor in the pressure of globalization on commodity prices (one of the reasons for subsidies; although the subsidies may be hurting more than they help. On top of this, other industry such as manufacturing has been greatly reduced.
Soil quality may compound these issues through reduced yield. But even with better soil, the economics of the region are unlikely to change in my opinion.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoFunny thing is that (small back then ?) farmers were the ones that fought for globalization (and against railway barons), with their Populist party, for easier export of their goods worldwide ! https://harpers.org/archive/2020/05/how-the-anti-populists-stopped-bernie-sanders/ https://harpers.org/archive/2020/05/how-the-anti-populists-s...
- chubot 4y agoThe documentary talks a lot about economics of farming, including the perverse incentives created by government subsidies Regenerative farming is cheaper in the long run because you're not buying fertilizer (they talk about how much that costs), and because soil with plant matter retains water The yields are higher, and diverse crops mean more potential sources of income However it probably doesn't produce results in the first year, and it takes more knowledge and skilled labor -- you can't just apply a formula to any piece of land. It takes some local knowledge, which farmers used to have, but can be lost when factory farms come in
- giantg2 4y agoSure, you could grow diverse crops. Some small farms do and then sell it restaurants, sell their "system" or knowledge, etc (and theres still debate about their economic viability). However, that won't apply to all the land. Commodity crops are in demand, so the majority of the land will be used for that. Most farmers wouldn't be interested in diverse crops due to the cost of various equipment, difficulty in marketing, and potential labor needs. Bill Gates is all about the environment and owns tons of farm land. Is he implementing regenerative farming, or just business as usual? I'd be interested to see if he's adopted it, or why he hasn't.
- feet 4y agoThose crops are only in demand because of ridiculous subsidy making them cheap
- giantg2 4y agoI highly doubt that. What else are we going to feed the animals for meat? If we cut back on meat, we would likely see an increase in soy demand. The subsidies might have created the demand, but now that we are in this lifestyle removing the subsidies will not reverse it fully. Edit: why disagree?
- myshpa 4y agoMore than three-quarters (77%) of global soy is fed to livestock for meat and dairy production. https://ourworldindata.org/soy https://ourworldindata.org/soy
- giantg2 4y agoOk... and what replaces that if we just decide not subsidize soy anymore? Under the current conditions, it seems consumption will only drop slightly and people will simply pay more. Just as we saw in the pandemic with China sourcing its soy.
- myshpa 4y agoNo, we should decide to stop subsidizing meat/dairy. Soy production (in moderate quantities) is not harmful to the planet, animal agriculture is.
- feet 4y agoSoy monoculture farming is harmful
- feet 4y agoIs soy the natural prey of cows, pigs, and sheep or do they eat other things if left to their own devices?
- ghouse 4y agoSoil fertility is similar to irrigation. As fertility decreases, it can be compensated (to a point) by fertilizer, but at an increased cost. As the aquifers are pumped faster than they are replenished, water can be pumped from deeper depths, but also at an increased cost. Both impact the economics of farming. And for many communities where agriculture is the economic foundation, decades of non-sustainable practices have created economic headwinds. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ogallala_Aquifer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ogallala_Aquifer (primary aquifer in the midwest) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optima_Lake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optima_Lake (lake never filled due to decrease in aquifer depth)
- giantg2 4y agoThings can certainly get worse. However, I don't see cheaper water or less fertilizer changing the economic outlook. Even with a slight increase in profit, you still have things like health insurance that are ever increasing, and the top line is too low to begin with.