4 ms·
> As Eddie Izzard once memorably pointed out, you get a lot of car chases in movies; very few car chases in books though. > So in movies we see ‘action’ emerge
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> As Eddie Izzard once memorably pointed out, you get a lot of car chases in movies; very few car chases in books though.
> So in movies we see ‘action’ emerge as a distinct genre, with ‘thriller’ left for more Hitchcockian psychological excitement
I would say that e.g. The Da Vinci Code is written with pacing that would make me characterize it as a "thriller". There's no psychological excitement going on there.
I don't think it's true that you don't see car chases, or their equivalent, in books.
- jameshart 4y agoWell no, the Da Vinci Code can not be accused of embodying any form of excitement - psychological or otherwise. And are you characterizing the multi chapter long taxi ride of exposition from the Da Vinci code as a car chase?
- bitwize 4y agoThe Da Vinci Code actually has car chases in it. You can practically see the action movie that was playing in Dan Brown's head. It's a profoundly idiotic movie, and if anything Hollywood probably improved on it, but still. Brown's style is cinematic, or at least cinematic-aspirant.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoIt's a profoundly idiotic book. But the pacing achieves its goals. You're not bored while you're reading it. What people get out of reading The Da Vinci Code, or other books in that style, is the same thing they get out of watching thriller movies. So I think it makes sense to call the book a thriller. > Brown's style is cinematic, or at least cinematic-aspirant. This is an interesting comment. I didn't get that vibe from Dan Brown. But Brandon Sanderson's Steelheart struck me, while I was reading it, as an effort to put a movie into book form. I was completely unsurprised to later learn he'd shopped out the movie rights.