3 ms·
Furthermore, looking at almost 26k GitHub stars for this repository, if only about 14% of the people who this resource is useful for, sponsored me with a one ti
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Furthermore, looking at almost 26k GitHub stars for this repository, if only about 14% of the people who this resource is useful for, sponsored me with a one time amount of a single Euro, I could order a new machine that probably lasted me another eight years. It's not something I'd expect, nor think I should. It's entirely my issue.
It's unseemly that people have to beg like this. I would be happy to pay a small annual Github subscription if it were distributed back to repo maintainers. Same thing with all the 'buy me a coffee' tags and now the 'buy me a slice of pizza' ones. Instead of funding useful bodies of work with meaningful micro-grants you have projects competing to provide people with better cups to rattle.
- simonw 4y agoThat's pretty much what GitHub Sponsors is.
- car 4y agoExcept it's targeted to whomever I feel like sponsoring. Maybe an additional way could be distribution of a general sponsorship fund based on the number of stars or another measure of merit/popularity? I've sponsored individual projects on GitHub before, but would prefer this way.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYes, that's my point. It's another market, and while markets have a lot of utility they also tend towards bimodal distributions which disproportionately reward a very successful and visible participants while disproportionately exploiting a much larger group. A pure market system has higher entropy than one which features some redistribution. https://arxiv.org/pdf/cond-mat/0001432.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/cond-mat/0001432.pdf
- elashri 4y agoIf something like this is going to be based on number of stars, imagine how this will turn the current "give us a star on github" to.
- dylan604 4y agoa game just like amazon reviews. if there's a system that can generate money that is able to be gamed, it will be. star ratings on git hub will become next to useless as it will no longer be used for anything other than monetization.
- luxcem 4y agoI think in France we had some interesting propositions for press funding based on this idea. Everyone paid a tax each year and gets token that they can attribute to the media they want. The fund are redistributed according to the tokens. I don't really like the idea of an automated measurement of merit / popularity. Let users decide and choose few projects they want to sponsor each year. Maybe show the current number of sponsor so big projects don't get all the votes.
- janeway 4y agoAnd Marx and Engles philosophy :D
- ricardobeat 4y agoThis kind of knowledge has historically been shared for free. We are not entitled to it, as much as the author is not entitled to compensation. At the risk of being downvoted to oblivion, I’ll say this: asking for donations is great, complaining that people are “leeching” your CC-licensed content, not so much. If you don’t have the bandwidth to maintain a project, just stop. Humanity will be fine. This move to monetize everything is a huge step backwards (or forwards into the abyss…).
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis move to monetize everything is a huge step backwards The guy can't afford to replace his 10 year old laptop, meantime rents and profits are at an all-time high. Seems like there's a few segments missing in the virtuous circle.
- prepend 4y agoOr it’s hyperbole and there are many reasons the guy has a 10 year old laptop. People donating a euro for a list of commands is unlikely when 10 euros gives them a billion hours a month on Netflix. The marginal value of these commands is really, really low when you start comparing it to all the stuff that people could spend. Most everyone has high rents and old laptops.
- hrbf 4y agoAuthor here. I don't expect people to pay me for anything. My main motivation was (and still is) to just give back, since I profit from free information and software created by others as well. I fully expect this temporary increase in traffic to net exactly what it has netted before: almost nothing. And you know what? I'm fine with that. Donations are not the reason this little project exists. What I am is struggling to make ends meet for some time. A new laptop is near the bottom of my priorities right now. Money will run out around the beginning of February. It makes me sad to read cynical comments like this. That's all I have to say.
- 4y ago
- eikenberry 4y agoI think the author doesn't get GitHub stars. They don't mean "I use this and like it", they are simply bookmarks. A way to find something interesting again. I don't think I actively use anything I starred. Or am I the odd one out?
- bschwindHN 4y agoI use it the same way - "oh this is interesting and I may want to use this later" presses star button
- luxcem 4y agopresses star button, never read it again
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis is what bookmarking in your browser is for. Not here for whines about convenience, if the maintainer can see it then you're sending a signal.
- bschwindHN 4y agoPeople place way too much importance on github stars. I will continue "bookmarking with stars" and not using half the things I star :)
- KyeRussell 4y agoThis is a misunderstanding but it is far from unusual. For one, the JavaScript package ecosystem is incredibly vain and is absolutely obsessed with these sorts of deeply flawed measurements of popularity.
- bshanks 4y agoThe university system is a mechanism to fund public goods. The problem is the professors are judged according to their production of novel knowledge, and maintaining useful software does not produce novel knowledge. We should endow chairs of "open-source professors", who are judged according to their production/maintenance of useful software, in order to re-use the infrastructure of the university system to fund this other type of public good.