3 ms·
The object falling in has its time dilated to forever - it will never actually experience the "getting there". Outside observers, on the other hand, will observ
by dotancohen 4y ago
The object falling in has its time dilated to forever - it will never actually experience the "getting there". Outside observers, on the other hand, will observe the "getting there" just as if the black hole were any other large mass.
Or do I have that backwards...
- birdiesanders 4y agoBackwards
- dotancohen 4y agoThank you!
- WrtCdEvrydy 4y agoYes, the outside observers can see the item falling into the blackhole while the object experiences more and more time dilation. If you were falling into a wormhole, you would die of old age before getting there while outside observers would see you fall in quickly.
- alonmower 4y agoYou would be ripped apart instantaneously while everyone outside of the black hole would see the light you emit as you’re crossing the event horizon frozen in time. It’s an optical effect, nothing magical is happening to you as you fall into the enormous mass
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoLike the comment you were responding to, you have that backward.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoYou have that backwards. The person falling into the black hole falls straight towards the singularity as if it was any other massive object, straight through the event horizon without noticing anything change. The far away observer sees the falling one infinitesimally approach the event horizon, but never cross.
- he0001 4y agoThis ”never cross” statement bends my mind. Doesn’t it also mean that if we are observers, observing a black hole, we should not see an actual blackness as we should only see things that are slowly falling into the hole? Regardless of how much time that has been spent from the beginning of time? I mean the event horizon is the boundary but that never happen?
- cthalupa 4y agoThe light is increasingly redshifted, so for practical purposes it disappears from view quite quickly. The more sensitive the instrument, the longer you can observe, and this doesn't really have a limit - as sensitivity approaches infinity, so does the length of time you could continue to observe the object. But for practical purposes, we would not see a black hole as some sort of weird psuedo-magnet with all sorts of junk stuck to the edge of the event horizon.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoBecause of time dilation, light emitted (or reflected off of) objects very near the event horizon end up getting spaced out over (almost infinite) amounts of time. For example, lets say you dropped a beacon that flashes every second into a black hole. As it approached the event horizon, you'd see the flashes only happen every 2 seconds, 4 seconds, minute, hour, decade, etc. Meanwhile, the length of those flashes are getting longer at the same rate, while producing the same number of photons, so the light gets dimmer and dimmer.
- he0001 4y agoAnother factor, that other things are falling into the whole, wouldn’t that mean that the event horizon, relatively, gets closer to an earlier object? Meaning an object may reach the event horizon faster than it would originally or is that constant relatively where the object exist in its descend?
- dylan604 4y ago>The person falling into the black hole falls straight towards I guess you're assuming zero velocity by that person. But if there is velocity, wouldn't the fall not be straight towards but in an ever shrinking/decaying orbit trajectory?