6 ms·
We in tech reinvented some of it: 1. Recite this problem from the Leetcode corpus as performance art (which FAANGs tell undergrads at top schools to spend mont
by neilv 4y ago
We in tech reinvented some of it:
1. Recite this problem from the Leetcode corpus as performance art (which FAANGs tell undergrads at top schools to spend months practicing, on top of their coursework, instead of exploring what interests them).
2. Demonstrate this particular method (which happened to be taught at our rich-kids alma mater, but no one else had heard of).
3. Now answer this culture question in STAR format (which we told you to take time ahead of time to practice, and to prepare correct answers, so you could speak them faux off-the-cuff, as a shibboleth).
It's upper classes creating the questionable gatekeeping rituals, and children of those classes who tend to have the spare time and coaching to best pass the filter.
- PaulHoule 4y agoTest prep is somewhat helpful for some people but some rich kids can't test their way out of a paper bag. Standardized tests are a route to social mobility for some. This guy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Webb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Webb came from a hardscrabble background in Missouri, standardized test results helped him get into the Naval Academy, he was a marine lieutenant in Vietnam, got a law degree, spent a lot of time in Asia as a journalist, wrote some novels including one about a guy who becomes a US Senator, actually became a US Senator representing Virginia. There is a lot of concern that attempts to get kids into gifted programs other than through testing will be influenced greatly by family SES https://ny.chalkbeat.org/2021/2/17/22288448/nyc-gifted-admissions-2021 https://ny.chalkbeat.org/2021/2/17/22288448/nyc-gifted-admis... There was that time I yelled at my son when he was a toddler and carried him under my arm out of a grocery store and somebody called child protective on me. They sent somebody to my house and fortunately my mother-in-law had just been cleaning and the house looked absolutely spotless, full of books, horses grazing in front of the house, at least middle if not upper class. They had no idea that my house doesn't even have central heat! Had they come to a hovel I could have had a very different outcome. They interviewed people and had a short investigation but based on appearances they saw what looked like "a good home" and might have gathered we'd have resources to fight them in court.
- mikeyouse 4y agoThere will always be people impacted positively and negatively by these decisions, so the presence of some people who benefitted from standardized tests doesn't say much about their rightful place in the world. In any case, Jim Webb is an exceptionally weird example to make that case, it's not like he grew up the son of a sharecropper -- his dad commanded a missile squadron for the Air Force and was a full Colonel when Webb joined the Naval Academy.
- whimsicalism 4y agoI think people really overestimate the likelihood of CPS taking their kid after a visit. There are lots of kids in absolutely horrid conditions that CPS doesn't take, they're not going to take them from your middle class home just because your mother in law didn't happen to clean.
- spiritplumber 4y agoGiven that CPS in Texas will attempt to take gender-non-conforming kids who have the support of their parents in being GNC, and that it's in Texas, I am pleasantly surprised that there have been no deaths with that policy.
- prottog 4y ago> surprised that there have been no deaths with that policy The lunacy of today's synthetic sex identity movement aside, what did you imagine, that the Texas state government would take these kids out back and shoot them?
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoTrans people denied gender-affirming treatment have monumentally higher suicide rates than their peers. You know that.
- mensetmanusman 4y ago
- fyresala 4y agoI've never understood why FAANGs are so fond of leetcode. Maybe they just get the headcounts and want a dumb and easy filter to hire some not terrible programmers. And that's part of the reason why the massive layoff is ongoing. But STAR costs you little time to practice and communication skills will definitely pay off for a programmer.
- whimsicalism 4y agoSTAR is what you do when you want to hire professional talkers. Leetcode is not the only way to hire professional builders, but is much better than STAR.
- ggambetta 4y agoI was surprised by the kind of things people openly admit to during STAR interviews. I don't enjoy doing them but they've surfaced enough red flags from candidates to save a previous employer a few bad hires.
- throwaway973591 4y agoI'd question whether it's really that effective. A dishonest candidate could craft a boring, safe scenario for a STAR interview question that paints them as an empathetic team-player, even if that's not how they've really acted in the past. Meanwhile, a forthright, but flawed candidate who supplies real examples from their past they regret, but would like to improve on, would look like an iffy hire.
- woooooo 4y agoLeetcode is the only thing that scales consistently. At small companies, a senior engineer can ask about past projects and get a sense of whether the candidate was a meaningful contributor or just along for the ride, but that's subjective and inconsistent when you have thousands of seniors.
- ghaff 4y agoLike the SAT, it probably does a reasonable job of providing a repeatable/scalable floor for skills that are a proxy for, if generally not the same as, what's needed for the job. And, like the SAT, the effort to prepare for the test is externalized.
- Aunche 4y ago> Demonstrate this particular method (which happened to be taught at our rich-kids alma mater, but no one else had heard of). This is one of those things that often gets repeated online, but I've never seen in practice. I've never seen a Leetcode interview question that can't be solved with knowledge outside of what you'd learn after the first semester of sophomore year. Helping my wife with Leetcode, I can see why some people would think this way though. Some people simply have better algorithmic intuition than others, so that may come off as memorization. The only somewhat esoteric questions I've been asked is Indian immigrants asking about the minutiae about the JVM. Even then, I don't think these would be unreasonable if you were explicitly screening for Java developers.
- a1pulley 4y agoThe alternative is gating on soft skills and job experience. Do you really think it's easier for privileged kids to game our industry's admissions tests? A poor kid would have a much harder time developing soft skills and getting job experience than a rich kid would have passing our admissions tests, which would be worse for social mobility than the status quo. A poor kid with a blue collar dad can't get an internship at his dad's friend's startup. A poor kid didn't go to a high school with a computer science club. A poor kid didn't grow up developing soft skills at a dozen different after school activities. However, the poor kid can go to college on a Pell Grant (like me), study hard, and at least have a chance to meet the Leetcode bar and gain entry to the middle class.
- somrand0 4y agotruly privileged "kids" ain't going around looking for jobs thorough interviews, they show up as "investors" or are otherwise brought in by their 'connections'...
- msla 4y agoGranted, but we're talking about upper-middle-class versus poor. Upper-middle-class means you speak the prestige dialect, you know what "business casual" means and you already have the proper outfit, and you have access to the relevant technology at home, not to mention free time to use it.
- WalterBright 4y agoA servicable laptop at the pawn shop can be had for $200.
- somrand0 4y agobut the internet no longer teaches you how to use it that content has been paywalled.
- eyphka 4y agoChiming in to agree here. Standardized tests + leetcode tests gave me the ability to overcome being a ward of the state and become a software engineer/ then founder of a YC company with zero connections. Quick aside, in addition to the Pell Grant, there's also for former foster youth the CHAFEE grant (California specific).
- aswanson 4y agoUpper class folks send their kids into law & medicine. Technology is more of a proletariat aspiration.
- WalterBright 4y ago> tell undergrads at top schools to spend months practicing Come on. A friend of mine spent 2 weeks studying the leetcode corpus and then passed Google's coding screening. He complained about having to do the study, and I suggested that Google's salaries were such that it would be the most cost-effective 2 weeks he'd ever spend.
- MaximumYComb 4y agoIt all depends on how good you are at programming / math. If you have a natural talent for those then you don't need to spend much time preparring (hence why they're used a test). People try to "cheat" the test through preparing for months.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf a person has to study leetcode for months, then either the person: 1. doesn't know much of anything about programming, and should consider taking programming courses 2. is just not cut out to be a high level programmer, and should consider a career path more suited to their abilities
- fragmede 4y agoThat's just the problem though, isn't it? Because the leetcode format is known, unless the person tells you, how would you know they studied for months to pass it? Brilliant person A does leetcode for a week to get the hang of the format, then interviews and gets a job offer. Person B who just isn't brilliant but is highly motivated, studies leetcode for months, interviews, and also gets the job. You might have fantasies of outlawing "studying for months for the test" but be real. Person whos "is just not cut out to be a high level programmer, and should consider a career path more suited to their abilities", it turns out, is doing just fine with their career path having studied for the test. I also think calendar time is the wrong way to measure it, since there's a huge difference between studied leetcode for 40 hours a week like it's your job or being in school; and studied leetcode for 4 hours on Friday nights instead of going out, for months.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s a poorly implemented method to attempt to introduce some equity or actual measurable outcome. It has to be poorly implemented because people have successfully asserted in court that assessments that correlate with IQ are illegal. So making an assessment a grind is key to weeding out the lazy or people not crafty enough to figure out what’s up. They handle the intelligence part by targeting select schools. In government, this has been incredibly impactful. Professional civil service jobs in the US had a mixture of professional expertise and general intelligence component weighted differently depending on the job. Now, if they still exist, they consist of trivia or grammar evaluations. The result is, in professional civil service, professions without gating credentials are hiring lower IQ individuals.