3 ms·
>Like most online culture, it all feels so profound until you realize that he hasn’t said anything at all. So pretty much like TFA... Which is basically a virt
by coldtea 4y ago
>Like most online culture, it all feels so profound until you realize that he hasn’t said anything at all.
So pretty much like TFA... Which is basically a virtue signalling hit piece (the target even asks "if they're planning to write a hit piece").
"The content of his work would repel, or simply confuse, a traditional viewer"
... and then the author points to a screenshot of a tweet (the "drop out of college, default on your student loans" etc (of which the most controversial part is about not getting the covid vaccine) that would seem totally quaint under lots of pretty tame contexts (from 60s counter-culture and 70s punk fanzines all the way to modern leftists), as if the average Joe is the standard after which anything becomes scary...
>To 99.9 percent of the population, Charlie is nobody
So just like the author?
- hacym 4y agoYou’re weirdly trying to attack the author. Why is that?
- throwaway346434 4y agoThe author did exactly what the subject of the critical opinion piece did, but did a worse job of it and was entirely unself critical.
- shanebellone 4y agoGood morning, Charlie.
- coldtea 4y agoBecause I don't like reading shallow hit jobs, and I think it's not just sloppy writing, but reflects to their authors too.
- hacym 4y agoHow is an opinion piece a shallow hit job? If you’re reading this as some credible news… stop?
- throwaway346434 4y agoPicture this article being written a vi/vim user; about all of those "freaks who use emacs". At some point you realise the writer is doing the same kind of thing as the people described, their criticisms make a low effort to understand and declare the "other side" wrong, for reasons that are basically "I didnt like it". From other comments here, I've since learned there is plenty to criticise about the speech, actions, behaviour of this individual, which is trivial to discover.
- hacym 4y agoSo you’re comparing someone who has encouraged young women to kill themselves to someone who users eMacs? I think you need to reevaluate your life.
- LastTrain 4y agoSo clearly all you did was get angry about a couple of lines in the article that were disparaging to Charlie. Did you not read the whole thing and understand the larger point? That Charlie is likely in the small group of people today who are setting the norms for tomorrow?
- coldtea 4y ago>So clearly all you did was get angry about a couple of lines in the article that were disparaging to Charlie. Rather, I read the whole thing, and grasped its tone, intention, and structure. >That Charlie is likely in the small group of people today who are setting the norms for tomorrow? Charlie and his "influence" is insignificant to the "norms of tomorrow", and if you take away the jabs at "weirdos" like Charlie from the article, the only thing that remains is a tired old "online vs offline" diatribe, the kind of which has been written 200 times a day since 1997 or so.
- rideontime 4y agoUnlike Charlie, the author isn't pretending not to be a nobody.