3 ms·
Even if the traditional image of a VN probe were impossible, and I doubt that, the effect of a traditional VN probe is unambiguously also achievable with a big
by ben_w 4y ago
Even if the traditional image of a VN probe were impossible, and I doubt that, the effect of a traditional VN probe is unambiguously also achievable with a big enough group of humans and tools.
On this scale, 10 MT of industrial equipment and 100k people that self-replicates in 35 years, isn't particularly different from a fancy hypothetical atomic 3D printer that masses 1kg, needs another 1kg of support equipment, and which self-replicates in 6 months.
- ianai 4y agoThe VN probe thing was mostly a mechanism to make the point for having a prohibition on a civilization becoming too grabby. Maybe the UFOs and such are the local galactic “police” looking for civilizations that would want to participate in a vast diversity of life in the future universe and acting as a backstop in case someone gets too grabby.
- trashtester 4y ago> Maybe the UFOs and such are the local galactic “police” Greg Bear had a series on this. I think this concept may depend on FTL travel/communication, though, at least in order to work well. Or at least on communication being much faster than travel. (In other words, if the speed of light is the limit, if VN probes are restricted to much slower speeds, the "Police" may be able to contain them, but if they're too fast, the probles will spread faster than the "Police" may stop the spread). And if the Policing is not done by a single civ, but is something that was set up by a coalition of civs that may exists 100s of thousands of light years apart, I think FTL communication is basically required to be able to even create such a coalition in the first place. My personal gut feeling, is that we're simply first in this area of Space.