3 ms·
> Goodreads , or rather parent company Amazon, has decided to deprecate theirs. That’s really the money quote, right there. When we depend on the work of othe
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
> Goodreads , or rather parent company Amazon, has decided to deprecate theirs.
That’s really the money quote, right there.
When we depend on the work of others, we also depend on the people and organizations behind that work. You really can’t get much bigger and more solid than Amazon (or Google, who are also infamous for drowning their babies), so “bus factor” is really a meaningless metric, when it comes to whether or not to depend on a service. I've been experiencing rug-pulls for most of my career (I'm an Apple developer, and Apple does this frequently).
I recently had to stop working on the app that I’m developing, and spend a month and a half, writing a new backend server and SDK, because the developer of a server I had depended on, has ghosted our project. I understand why they did it (life happens), but the reasons make no difference. They still ended up leaving us in the lurch. I actually have a huge amount of respect for the author, count them as a personal friend, and sincerely wish them nothing but the best.
That project ticked a lot of Buzzword Bingo boxes: Postgres, postgis, containers, Django, Python, etc. Also, the main author is fairly young.
But it was painfully slow. It was killing our app. It’s entirely possible that we could have sped it up, but it required working closely with the author for a while, and that relationship withered, as noted.
So I wrote my own server, using “boring” tech; PHP, MySQL, etc. It’s lickety-split fast, secure, simple, well-documented, maintainable, adaptable to multiple data inputs (the original server was for a single data source), and doesn’t require a container to deploy. It’s also fairly easy to switch the DB tech, and it can be deployed on a wide range of low-cost servers, which helps, as it’s a free app, for a nonprofit.
I’m not against dependencies, despite frequent sneers and insults, assuming that I’m some “out of touch boomer,” clutching the past. I think that modular software development (a very old technique, by the way) is how we can do high Quality, at scale, and rapidly. In fact, that’s exactly how I work.
It’s just that I tend to write my own dependencies. I have a fair bit of faith in myself.