4 ms·
South Australia had to test one for real in the big storms a few years back. "It's harder than it looks" time. Two contracted gas turbine black start sources di
by ggm 4y ago
South Australia had to test one for real in the big storms a few years back. "It's harder than it looks" time. Two contracted gas turbine black start sources didn't work and had pretty major contractual penalty issues.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is the main problem with a black start; you never get a chance to test it until you're in a black start scenario. And since it is never tested, it's almost guaranteed to fail in some unexpected way. And since that's the case, almost anything is better then getting yourself into a black start scenario, including shedding load in any possible way. Which leads to it never being tested, and more things being unknowingly broken.
- jefftk 4y agoI don't see why you can't test it: take one of these contracted sources, disconnect it from the grid, and verify it can start on its own. What am I missing?
- bombcar 4y agoThat's testing one source; and you CAN do that but you may find that there are things you didn't realize because the grid was actually UP. For example, the entire station may be disconnected from the grid, but somewhere in the system is a Siemens device that for whatever ungodly reason needs to access the internet, which works when the grid as a whole is operational but fails when it can't get cell service. And even if those stations work correctly, you still haven't verified that the actual plan is operational because you haven't actually done the black start; perhaps the grid divisions are incorrect and the first load you try to apply will brown out the start source.
- jefftk 4y agoI agree there are other things that can go wrong, but the "two contracted gas turbine black start sources didn't work" problem does still seem like something that probably could have been avoided with regular testing?
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, we certainly should be doing as much as we can, but it seems time and time again we keep finding things to fix only when it's actually forced to test. It's the same reason that datacenters don't just run the generators every month, but actually switch over to generator power and disconnect from the grid to verify it works (and if it doesn't, hopefully the batteries last long enough to get back to the grid!).
- slv77 4y agoAnd then during an actual outage you find out that generator conks out 15 minutes after startup because the fuel filters are clogged. Between tests enough fuel would have leaked through the clogged filters to create a 15 minute revisor but during an actual outage the filters can’t keep up.
- badcppdev 4y agoYou're missing the bit where you use the black start source to start the other sources.
- V__ 4y agoBut that's just partially true. Sure, you can't test the whole system at once. But testing each station separately is totally doable. Seems like there was no oversight to check whether the claims made by the station were factual and tested.
- boruto 4y agohttps://www.iitk.ac.in/npsc/Papers/NPSC2016/1570292920.pdf https://www.iitk.ac.in/npsc/Papers/NPSC2016/1570292920.pdf Looks like they do test the procedure.