3 ms·
> The most annoying one, is that the app always defaults to the closest location "as the bird flies." I've got a similar annoyance with basically every app or
by tzs 4y ago
> The most annoying one, is that the app always defaults to the closest location "as the bird flies."
I've got a similar annoyance with basically every app or website that offers to find things within N miles of me. I live in Western Washington on the other side of Puget Sound from Seattle.
Say the first two options they give me for N are 10 miles and 25 miles.
10 miles is too small. I need more than that to include Bremerton, Silverdale, and Poulsbo, which are the three most likely places that I'll find whatever I'm looking for if it exists over here.
But 25 miles means the circle reaches past Puget Sound and includes Seattle, Bellevue, and even some of Redmond.
For example if I'm searching for Target stores and enter my zip code, their search lists my nearest store first, then 13 stores on the Seattle side (5 in Seattle, 2 in Bellevue, and 1 each in Lynnwood, Everett, Redmond, Renton, Tukwila, and Woodinville) before the store that is actually second closest to me as far as actually driving goes (Gig Harbor).
- withinboredom 4y agoI used to sell store locator software and this is always a problem. We worked on allowing “masks” over water that basically added a penalty for any vector that passed over the mask. It’s a hard problem at any kind of scale though and even this solution wasn’t perfect (imagine a river with no bridges or ferries only)
- initplus 4y agoThe correct solution is to use an isochrone rather than a basic radius search. Or to simply sort all the shores within the max search radius using a vehicle routing library/api.
- withinboredom 4y agoThat doesn’t work at scale unless you have an api with unlimited request throughput or knowledge of where water is (again needing access to the raw map or unlimited api access). In this case, the stores had to mark their own masks on the map.