3 ms·
I don't understand the argument that Javascript isn't free. Every library I'm aware of is MIT or otherwise FOSS licensed, and (at least before Node.js and NPM c
by krapp 4y ago
I don't understand the argument that Javascript isn't free. Every library I'm aware of is MIT or otherwise FOSS licensed, and (at least before Node.js and NPM came along) it isn't owned or licensed by a specific corporation. It's probably the most free programming language ever created.
It's RMS, so I know he's going to throw the baby out with the bathwater on this, then throw out the bathtub, then disassemble the plumbing, brick up the bathroom and never bathe again on principle, but Javascript has probably served as a greater benefit for FOSS culture than any other language. Certainly more so than lisp. Making it out to be an implicitly evil language seems... out of touch?
quick edit: I know the argument about privacy invading javascript software, but software can be free and still invade your privacy. That's got nothing to do with the language.
- teddyh 4y agoJust to explain, the non-free code JavaScript code he is referring to is the inline JavaScript code on individual web pages (which in turn often uses the large MIT-licensed libraries).
- zelphirkalt 4y agoThe JS mess has brought us megabyte huge blobs of minified JS that does who knows what, slowing down getting information to a crawl compared to what could be. Not all JS is like that, but a lot of people are actively participating in creating that mess.
- Unrectified 4y agoI do think reading https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap.html is helpful to understand his position. Specially if you're familiar with his 'four freedoms' concept
- brenns10 4y agoI'm not a fan of RMS, but as you noted, his blurb in the talk wasn't "Javascript the language is not free", or even "Javascript the ecosystem is not free", it's about the privacy invading factor of JS in a modern web browser. Since, as you said, software can be free and still invade your privacy. He just doesn't want this GNU project to include support for a language whose primary purpose seems to be invading privacy -- even if it has a lot of great secondary purposes and a good open source ecosystem. Given that the GNU/FSF projects are all about advocacy in the area of software freedom and privacy, it seems like a reasonable perspective to have. Yeah, RMS definitely takes things to an extreme, but I don't see the "JS is implicitly evil" thing you're calling out, just refusing to appear to endorse or support something that goes against his principles. And of course ironically enough those very principles mean he (should be...) perfectly happy with the emacs-ng fork, since that's part of the freedom he's advocating for.
- masukomi 4y agoyes, js can be used to invade privacy, but... a) that's not its primary use by a long shot. The VAST majority of JS written has nothing to do with tracking / privacy stuff. b) we don't need JS to invade your privacy on the web... Does he browse without images turned on too?! (and i recognize you're just explaining his position not arguing against JS)
- jodrellblank 4y ago> “b) we don't need JS to invade your privacy on the web... Does he browse without images turned on too?” He doesn’t really browse the web at all: “””How I use the Internet I am careful in how I connect to the internet. Specifically, I refuse to connect through portals that would require me to identify myself, or to run any nontrivial nonfree Javascript code. I use LibreJS to prevent nonfree Javascript code from running. I am careful in how I use the Internet. I generally do not connect to web sites from my own machine, aside from a few sites I have some special relationship with. I usually fetch web pages from other sites by sending mail to a program (see https://git.savannah.gnu.org/git/womb/hacks.git https://git.savannah.gnu.org/git/womb/hacks.git) that fetches them, much like wget, and then mails them back to me. Then I look at them using a web browser, unless it is easy to see the text in the HTML page directly. I usually try lynx first, then a graphical browser if the page needs it. I occasionally also browse unrelated sites using IceCat via Tor. Except for rare cases, I do not identify myself to them. I think that plus Tor plus LibreJS is enough to prevent my browsing from being associated with me. “”” https://stallman.org/stallman-computing.html https://stallman.org/stallman-computing.html
- aidenn0 4y agoThe JavaScript on a typical web site is most definitely not free. Someone wholesale copied the Crunchyroll player code into a Kodi plugin and got a (legitimate) DMCA takedown notice. On smaller sites there is no license, on commercial sites it's usually "all rights reserved"
- aidenn0 4y agoIt's too late to update, but most commercial sites no longer have an explicit "all rights reserve" message, presumably because minifiers remove the comments. However, in many jurisdictions (including the US) such a notice is optional anyways.