10 ms·
Identical twins aren't that identical
- gregw134 4y agoI'm an identical twin. I remember twice in high school we were accused of cheating because we wrote extremely similar essays, but in fact we both randomly came up with the same very specific idea at the same time.
- cperciva 4y agoAll you know for certain is that you didn't cheat and your twin claims that he didn't copy your work. ;-)
- Retric 4y agoHardly, they also know if their twin had the opportunity to copy their work etc.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoThoughts are highly genetic.
- lukas099 4y agoI think you can make a pretty strong case for nurture here. The twins talk and hang out a lot, so they develop similar thought patterns.
- casion 4y agoYou can't disentangle nature from nurture with some sets of twins as they are both in play. That's part of why it's fascinating to see both with strong simultaneous reinforcement, and similarly when the "nurture" part is removed and the chances of similarities is higher than normal.
- lukas099 4y agoYes, we are lucky to have identical twins in the world if for nothing else than the scientific research they enable.
- waterhouse 4y agoSome studies look at identical twins vs fraternal twins, seeing if identical twins are more similar than fraternal. It's an excellent way to control for almost everything except the genetics.
- cperciva 4y agoThe gold standard is "separated twins" studies, looking at identical twins who are adopted away to different families at birth. Sadly for science but happily for the families involved, these are getting harder to do; the primary source of such twins used to be unmarried women who became pregnant, but between the availability of birth control and a dramatic reduction in the social stigma, far fewer children are being "hidden" by being adopted away.
- senectus1 4y agooooh not sure i agree with that. Thats a very slippery slope as well.
- ARandomerDude 4y agoI wish I could agree with you but I’m helplessly bound by my DNA to think you’re wrong.
- pge 4y agoidentical twin too - my brother and I were accused of cheating on standardized test once in elementary school because our answers were so similar. Got called into the Principal's office. Fortunately, we were sitting far enough apart that there was no way we could have cheated. Certainly with my brother and me, our answers to any kind of test at that age were highly correlated, just from having had similar (or the same) teachers and having similar aptitude.
- giantg2 4y agoThe more interesting part for me would be if they explored more about how it was determined they were cheating and what the punishment was - ie the entire basis for the case. Imagine all the money wasted on this case when a simple solution existed. Think they cheated? Create a different test of the material and administer it separately.
- sorenjan 4y agoI don't like the term identical twins, it confuses some people and invites the kind of anecdotes described in the article. People are different individuals even when they have the same DNA. I prefer the term monozygotic twins.
- overgard 4y agoIdentical twin here. I know me and my brother were very similar academically despite being in different classes and never studying together. I imagine if these twins happened to study together, it seems plausible they scored similarly, and if you factor in pace, they probably think and work at a similar energy level. They dont get into how they got to the 10^38 figure, but to me that seems like the most fishy part. To prove cheating you need more than odd movements and similar scores in my opinion.
- runsWphotons 4y agoYou dont need more than odd movements for the invigilator to suspect them of something weird going on and remove them from the test. They could have just retested them later. The calculation was done only after the invigilator noticed strange movements and noted them so that the tests were looked into more.
- thayne 4y ago> They dont get into how they got to the 10^38 figure, but to me that seems like the most fishy part If the test was multiple choice with 5 options for each question, and you assume that if they got the question wrong, they randomly guessed the answer, and their answers to all incorrect questions were independent of each other, and forget to account for the fact that one of those 5 options is correct (or there were 6 options, which is less common for exams in my experience), then you get approximately 1 in 10^38 for the probability their wrong answers were all the same. But those are bad assumptions. People don't randomly guess the answer every time they answer incorrectly, and people who have shared experiences (like say taking the same classes) are more likely to answer the same way. And answers to different questions are probably correlated, especially in such a long test, where there are likely multiple questions covering similar material. Now, it is possible that computed the probability a different way, and it is just a coincidence they came to the same number. After all, the above method doesn't account for how likely it is that they answered correctly on the 242 other questions they answered the same, which would probably require some analysis of other students who took the same exam and maybe how similar the twins were on previous exams. But it does seem suspicious that it is easy to get the same number with a very naive estimation.
- pram 4y agoI have twin girls and they’re not similar at all. I don’t believe the hive-mind hypothesis. TBH they do a lot of shenanigans to screw with people who aren’t familiar with them, like going by the opposite name. An elaborate cheating scheme seems like something they’d enjoy.
- CalChris 4y agoIdentical twin here. In high school, we had a brutal geometry problem set. The only people in the school who got it right were my twin brother and I. Pretty cool. We were in separate sections; by then, we really didn't like being the same class. I was in the second section and was accused of cheating by the teacher with zero evidence; the correct answers, it was math, were going to be the same. My response was the fuck we did; we were competing against each other. The teacher knew he wasn't going to get past that and changed the subject. But going from only to cheater to next didn't sit well. As for the article, what is the bitrate of odd movements? BTW, we may have cheated at one point. 24 Hour Fitness had a less well known half-price for twins membership. Or at least, I think they did.
- nanidin 4y agoredacted
- EGreg 4y agoActually, he was right, and your version is incorrect. “I was the only one who…” On the other hand you’d be correct in a phrase like: “The only people who were cheated were his brother and me.” The word me is an object of a sentence, not the subject.
- singlow 4y agoThe "brother and I" are a compound complement, not an object. Complements use the same form as the subject. Were is a form of "to be" which generally sees subject forms on both sides, such as "It is I". The only one who got it right was I. The only ones who got it right were he and I.
- singlow 4y agoI will also add that myself is only for a few specific cases, primarily when the subject and object are the same: I looked at myself in the mirror. She looked at me. I have decided to just be myself. Kind of an odd case there. I, myself, love to go to the movies. Here it is just used for emphasis, not as an actual reflexive pronoun. Some people do use the reflexive pronoun as an object in certain cases, often with compound objects, but it is not proper under any prescriptive English grammar that I have studied.
- phlipski 4y agoIdentical twin here. My brother and I are/were completely different academically. I excelled in math/school - he struggled. I graduated with an engineering degree, he didn't and struggled in high school and college. He ultimately did earn his bachelors degree - but not until his late 30's. There are some area's where we share similar thoughts, and some where we drastically diverge. To this day when I look at baby pics from ages 0 to around 3 I have no clue which one is me unless the pic has been labeled. I'm now the father of twin girls (fraternal) and they are basically two completely different human beings who happened to share the same womb and birthday. They are NOTHING alike. I also have 2 other siblings, and though I communicate the least with my twin these days - I still feel and share a bond with him that I'll never have with my other siblings and I can't quite explain it. All that said I can't wrap my head around this idea that twins "think alike because they're twins." I think the simple answer to this case is that both of those women are smart and studied hard. And if you're really worried about it - put them in different classrooms and make them re-take the test. Sure would have saved a bunch of time and legal fee's!
- dotancohen 4y ago> I still feel and share a bond with him that I'll never have with my other siblings and I can't quite explain it. May I bother you with a request for perspective? A neighbour lost one of his identical twins at 6 months old. Both twins were born around 700 grams, and were under treatment (incubation possibly, but I'm not sure) in the house for many months. I do not know if they were together during treatment or not. The twin who lived does not know that she had a twin sister - at around age two or maybe three the family took down the photographs of the deceased twin and stopped talking about her. Might that have some lingering effects on the living twin? Of course I'm asking about the general case, not this specific case, because obviously I cannot provide enough information over a short HN comment. But in your opinion, as someone with an unexplainable bond unlike that with other siblings, might such a bond persist even had you not known about the existence of your twin? How might that affect you if so? To be clear, I have no intentions of revealing what I know and would never betray the parent's wishes.
- phlipski 4y ago
- bagels 4y agoThe statistics presented in the case were probably pretty flawed. The telepathy stuff also seems rediculous. The part I don't understand is: if the proctor sees identical twins sitting near eachother, and suspects them of communicating, why not just separate them instead of waiting until the test is over and then accusing them of cheating? Why not just remove the possibility for them to cheat?
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> The part I don't understand is: if the proctor sees identical twins sitting near eachother, and suspects them of communicating, why not just separate them instead of waiting until the test is over and then accusing them of cheating? Because by the time you notice that they're cheating, it's too late to retroactively prevent them from starting?
- bagels 4y agoThere was a lunch break, so it seems like it must have been a lengthy test. They could have at least stopped it from continuing.
- phire 4y agoMuch harder to move students now that tests are computerized. The software might not even support that functionality. Also, we have no idea what their suspected cheating procedures are. Maybe they deliberately avoid acting early on a hunch so they get a full test worth of data to run an statistical analysis on.
- zupa-hu 4y agoI had a classmate in secondary school with whom we seem to have shared a very similar brain wiring to the point where we wrote identical tests in physics. I believe for maybe two years. As soon as he got his result, I knew mine & vica versa. Was a strange experience, we did develop a special bond. We were never accused of cheating, it was a tiny group though (20). Edit: By identical, I do mean _literally_ the same mistakes, same points. Not 99% similar. 100%.
- robertakarobin 4y agoWe have identical boys, James and Charlie, about to turn 5. Got a DNA test for a holiday present that confirmed it. They're very healthy and happy kids, and are each other's best friend. When they were about 3, James asked to wear a dress. Now James wears a dress every day, and is -- for lack of a better word -- extremely flamboyant. At first Charlie wanted to wear a dress too, but that seems to have just been FOMO because now he never wears them. Charlie is maybe more cerebral and cautious than your average boy, but still very clearly feels like a boy. This has all been really interesting and mystifying to us. My wife and I and most of the people we interact with are pretty ordinary cisgendered, heterosexual people. We've never consciously pushed the boys toward any particular social norm. And we both figured one's sexuality and gender identity was hardcoded in one's DNA. Now we have living proof that doesn't seem to be the case. Our best uneducated guess is that something in utero caused the boys to develop with different levels of hormones, and that caused their "wiring" to diverge.
- guntri 4y agoPlease don't trans your kid just because he likes wearing dresses.
- robertakarobin 4y agoYes, we're careful to not put any labels on him. In his words, he doesn't like it when people call him a girl, and wants people to know he's a boy, but he does like to do things that girls do.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> And we both figured one's sexuality and gender identity was hardcoded in one's DNA. There are some good reasons not to believe this. From a Darwinian perspective, we can easily observe that homosexuality is one of the worst possible phenotypes an organism can have, so we'd expect genes to be adamantly opposed to it. Or in other words, heterosexuality definitely should be hardcoded in, in several different ways, but homosexuality should not. And the evidence, such as it is, tends to bear that out: concordance of homosexuality in identical twins is, if I remember correctly, about 40%. That sounds high, but it isn't -- concordance for randomly chosen traits in identical twins is much, much higher than 40%.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIs there any legal backstop in the US stopping someone from deciding to give both twin newborns the exact same name? Imagine the potential for criming.
- Cerium 4y agoAt least they would be different on their birth certificate. I know that California certificates have fields for number of births and birth number (eg: twins, 1/2).
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y agoOne step is to stop caring so much about DNA, glorified run-of-the-mill recipe for proteins and alike (is it really important with what soldering iron was the RAM soldered on your computer?), and start looking at bioelectrical patterns. If all a "person" is is some kind of dynamical pattern, a state machine, if you will, drawn by voltage-gated ion channels [1] and mechanisms alike, then there is nothing mysterious when similar state machines are in the same state: nothing out of the ordinary if I boot up two different but same specification devices with the same operating system and I land, even with different RAM mappings, on the "same" desktop. [1] Michael Levin: "Non-neural, developmental bioelectricity as a precursor for cognition" https://youtu.be/3Cu-g4LgnWs https://youtu.be/3Cu-g4LgnWs
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoThey probably calculated the original chances assuming independent random variables for answers, and the truth is that those variables are dependent and highly correlated because they are twins. Both the articles and the original out of thin air calculations are completely made up, but it's pretty conceivable that the cheating program had a mistaken assumption of variable independence, which is clearly false in this case.