> You got 3 new solutions that you were able to get working with some tweaking and one of them was an improvement. >> All of them looked great, but didn't work

> You got 3 new solutions that you were able to get working with some tweaking and one of them was an improvement. >> All of them looked great, but didn't work when tested. One worked when I changed it (having been pointed in the right direction), the other two just didn't work better than what I'd written, and were moot in terms of improvement.