3 ms·
You seem to be asserting a few contradictory things: 1. Taiwan can only be defended with US troops on the ground 2. Ukraine has no US troops on the ground and
by brookst 4y ago
You seem to be asserting a few contradictory things:
1. Taiwan can only be defended with US troops on the ground
2. Ukraine has no US troops on the ground and is being successfully defended
3. The US would only put troops on the ground to protect valuable things like TSMC fabs
4. (by implication) if China attacks Taiwan and destroys TSMC fabs tomorrow, the US would have no incentive to defend Taiwan because the fabs are gone
I don't see it. Ukraine looks likely to survive as a country without US troops on the ground. Ukraine, as you note, has no fabs or similarly valuable assets. Why can't those exact same conditions play out in Taiwan, which is also much much much harder to invade with ground troops than Ukraine was?
- Animatronio 4y ago1. The topic was US defense of TW. How exactly would it be defended by the US without troops? 2. Ukraine is defended by the Ukr army - with copious amounts of ammo and weaponry yes from NATO but no troops. At the same time the US never said they would send the army into conflict to defend it; when it comes to TW, despite the strategic ambiguity or whatever it's called, the general belief is there would be US boots on the ground. 3. The US would send its soldiers if there was something valuable obviously - be it fabs or oil or whatever, but not just to fight China for a random island in the Pacific. Otherwise they would have done it already on the countless atolls that are being fortified. 4. Yes, pretty much that. Just that it would not be obvious, but rather a long war of words would precede it... Again, nothing wrong with it. As long as no lives are lost I guess it is for the better.