3 ms·
> You still occasionally hear people saying that founders don't deserve to be rich, because their employees created all the value. What I actually hear people
by neilv 4y ago
> You still occasionally hear people saying that founders don't deserve to be rich, because their employees created all the value.
What I actually hear people saying (including at least one person from YC) is that founders need to share the potential wealth more fairly with early hires. With various rationales, including that execution is everything: having an idea and raising money for it isn't execution -- and the founders need the early hires to execute successfully.
> But the falsity of this claim becomes increasingly obvious as automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer and fewer employees.
I'm not following the logic, but the initial assertion seems like it'd tend to be received sloppily, anyway. Whether founders deserve to be rich seems like a diversion from the usual question: why do founders with a successful exit get rich when employees get even less than they would've been guaranteed at a non-startup tech job.
> In the limit case, you're left with just the founders. And we're not far from it. Instagram had only 13 employees when it was sold for a billion dollars.
So share the wealth with those 13 employees. "I have an idea for site/app" and getting some funding isn't worth a billion dollars. Successful execution is.
> And a billion was if anything below market price. People mocked that deal at the time, but in retrospect it was a bargain.
Isn't part of the job of those founders to make sure the exit is at market value? Were the wealth spread around more evenly, so that everyone who made the success possible can get rich, the founders might have more motivation to get a good price. :)
(I suppose that an exception to this would be if a startup is actually closer to an investment scam, propped up by other startups in a portfolio as customers, and they expect all the workers involved to do only mechanical tasks in which individual creativity/ideas/brilliance/etc. doesn't significantly affect the success of the company.)
- tartoran 4y ago> why do founders with a successful exit get rich when employees get even less than they would've been guaranteed at a non-startup tech job This is the question that if addressed would fix the whole startup scammyness and exploitation. But then it may as well kill startups.