4 ms·
There isn’t a mechanism to “force” anyone. With few exceptions, companies lease their office space. A few companies may try to force employees to sit in a lease
by brookst 4y ago
There isn’t a mechanism to “force” anyone. With few exceptions, companies lease their office space. A few companies may try to force employees to sit in a leased office to feed the sunk cost fallacy, but that won’t last. Only the most incompetent management will renew leases to support employees who don’t want to be there in the first place.
The actual solution is large scale conversion of commercial real estate to residential. Some people like being downtown, with population density, ability to walk to lots of restaurants, etc. And converting ~60% of office space to residential will drive costs down, reducing financial motivations to move out of the city.
Property owners are fucked, and will see much lower returns than they expected. Some will go bankrupt. Buildings financed by banks may see foreclosure/auction, and some banks will lose money. That’s what interest is for.
But eventually these buildings will have new owners that bought them at appropriate prices, and new purposes as residences, and downtown will probably be an even better place to live, with a population that doesn’t go home to the suburbs every night.
tl;dr: probably a good thing for downtown; invest in office-to-apartment conversion companies.
- showerst 4y agoHopefully! Keep in mind that other alternatives are possible, including “St. Louis and Detroit in the 80s-2000s” style downward spiral into blight. I have no interest in bailing out billion dollar property holding companies, but we need to do everything possible to encourage positive development. It does seem like many cities get it, the high line in particular seems to have spawned a dozen imitators which is awesome.
- ethagknight 4y agoLarge office towers just do not convert to residential very well. It can be done, it can be tolerated, it's just not a very good or competitive product, while also being very expensive to implement. One example, People walk a few blocks from the parking garage to their place of employment, but in most cities, people will not walk a few blocks from the parking garage to their home. Adding insult to injury, office towers that have been constructed in the last 50 years are very expensive to maintain, mechanical systems are expensive and complicated, requires a full-time staff to run. They were built for utilization at very different price point.
- brookst 4y ago> It can be done, it can be tolerated, it's just not a very good or competitive product I agree with everything you said, just want to highlight that this quote is the classic statement of a business opportunity. There is a VC pitch here: a company that acquired distressed office space at scale, from panicked sellers, and with the expertise to do these conversions in a systematic, cost-optimized way. Banks are going to want to unload these properties as soon as they appear, for dirt cheap. Someone is going to make a lot of money by approaching the issue as a tech problem.
- ethagknight 4y agoI work in the adaptive reuse industry converting history office buildings into hotels or apartments. We've looked at a number of modern era office towers, and housing is simply not viable. To your point though.. ironically, urban factories and warehousing seems to me to be the best use. Can you build a small electric vehicle or iPhones with the assembly line going from top to bottom? Banks are already there for unloading these properties. I can show you million-square-foot office towers today that are essentially free to acquire, but you get to pay tax, insurance, maintenance, keeping the lights on and functioning for any future use, a few million a year minimum, with no revenue. Some groups thought they could mine bitcoin, but the floor fell out of that. At the end of the day, since there are substantial costs involved with the tower itself relative to a warehouse, the tower should used for something that also requires a large number of people. A datacenter-type use is best if located near cheap electricity - not usually city centers. Lastly, office towers are usually located amongst excellent mass transit, even in cities with poor transit options, but the typical office tenant (bankers, lawyers, financiers) will not accept mass transit as an alternative to 1 parking space per employee. But factory workers will if it works!
- brookst 4y agoSuper interested in your industry! What makes conversion of office towers to housing not viable? It's easy for me to imagine a lot of objections to converting one building, but hard to imagine insurmountable difficulties in converting 1000, where you can amortize R&D and specialized equipment across a huge number of properties. So, if you don't mind humoring me, can you sketch the worst / most expensive / most technically difficult requirements for converting an office tower to apartments? I suspect you're probably right, given you've got domain knowledge and I don't, it just feels like one of those problems that becomes more tractable at scale.