4 ms·
It’s good news geopolitically, and the construction will produce a lot of jobs. But people should temper long-term job expectations. This huge of an investment
by brookst 4y ago
It’s good news geopolitically, and the construction will produce a lot of jobs. But people should temper long-term job expectations.
This huge of an investment in a tech where TSMC will face competition from fabs in lower-cost countries almost certainly means the company believes it can use extensive automation to avoid having labor costs sink their ability to compete on price.
(Yes, there may be a window where they don’t have to compete on price, but you build fabs for 5-10 years of production)
- bmitc 4y ago> It’s good news geopolitically I actually think the opposite. It will be good for global supply chains but not geopolitics, because it reduces the reliance on Taiwan thus opening it up for assimilation.
- baybal2 4y agoThat fab will not be even 1% of US semiconductor consumption. And it will come to a halt within weeks if consumables will stop coming from Taiwan.
- ianai 4y agoNope. Chips clearly have a national security component. Ensuring local supply reinforces national security. Which reinforces geopolitical commitments through making those commitments more credible. Edit-removed a comment
- mlindner 4y agoI think it actually increases assimilation with the US instead. One of the things that improved US relations with Japan when there was fear that they would take over the US was when they started building a bunch of US-based manufacturing.
- kibwen 4y agoThat's describing something different. In the 80s the US was worried that Japan would dominate the US economically. The dynamic here is that Taiwan is worried that China will dominate Taiwan militarily. The assimilation being referenced above is not between the US and Taiwan, but between the Taiwan and China.
- kube-system 4y agoThe US has no such fear about Taiwan. Taiwan has a fear that they will be invaded by China if they do not have industry that is too important to China to be interrupted by war.
- brookst 4y agoAre you saying China is more likely to invade Taiwan if the destruction of TSMC’s Taiwanese fabs could be mitigated by buying the same products from TSMC’s US-based fabs?
- ido 4y agoI believe what they are saying that the US is less likely to risk war with China to protect Taiwan if they can get chips sources domestically.
- kube-system 4y agoI phrased that wrong. I meant that they want to be important to the world in general (and the US), not specifically China.
- brookst 4y agoEven if it were bad for Taiwan, geopolitics is about more than Taiwan. But I’m not sure this is bad for Taiwan: today, China can wipe out TSMC overnight. With these fabs there will be Taiwanese revenue streams coming from mainland US, which streams can support Taiwan government and military. Walk me through why it’s bad for Taiwan to be more economically diversified?
- Animatronio 4y agoWell for one the US won't be so inclined to defend TW so much. Sure, there will be posturing, maybe even a proxy war like in Ukraine, but generally speaking the US will not be sending troops anymore, now that the golden goose has nested on its shores.
- mupuff1234 4y agoI'm guessing Taiwan received quite a carrot in order to get their approval for the TSMC expansion.
- Animatronio 4y agoNo carrot I'm afraid :D I think this decision was 100% made by TSMC and the US. Both get what they want: - continuity of operations and safety for TSMC - locally sourced chips for the US and most importantly - much diminished importance for Taiwan, meaning they do not have to defend it with troops (which is the most important aspect of war - see Afghanistan, Vietnam, and so on).
- boc 4y agoOr conversely the US will commit even more resources to the defense of Taiwan now that their own domestic supply of chips is safe. The US had no strategic interest in Ukraine yet we’ve all seen the reaction. The US will gladly defend Taiwan and create the hill for the CCP to die upon.
- Animatronio 4y ago
- totalZero 4y agoAbsent any form of fab redundancy in the global economy, the fabs make Taiwan fragile in the eyes of the Western powers. Taiwan is safer when it is not a pressure point for the entire Western economy because it's easier to defend territory that can withstand a few hits.
- yyyk 4y agoIt may be a useful talking point to get the public to do the right thing on Taiwan, but frankly there's no meaningful economic reliance on TSMC/Taiwan and policy makers know this.
- baybal2 4y ago
- mlindner 4y ago> This huge of an investment in a tech where TSMC will face competition from fabs in lower-cost countries almost certainly means the company believes it can use extensive automation to avoid having labor costs sink their ability to compete on price. What countries are you imagining that will suddenly become competitive in semiconductor manufacturing? As far as I know there are no up and coming companies of note. (Companies in China are not of note as they have been permanently prevented from further advancement.)
- sidibe 4y agoYup, this isn't making the cheapest t-shirts possible. The cost of labor is nothing compared to the revenues. For a fab you want a stable government and environment, and good tax/trade situation, and reliable, quality labor.
- anonymouslambda 4y ago"Permanently prevented" -- semi manufacturing is an engineering problem, not magic. Engineering problems can be solved, unless you think Chinese people are inherently inferior engineers.
- quonn 4y agoIt‘s not that easy to duplicate the institutional knowledge of companies like Zeiss, for example, otherwise they would have a lot of competition already.