3 ms·
I'll go one step further, it's total BS. :) I tested as a genius level IQ in elementary school. I went to special educational programs in grade 4-5, then a sch
by zikzak 4y ago
I'll go one step further, it's total BS. :)
I tested as a genius level IQ in elementary school. I went to special educational programs in grade 4-5, then a school with a stream just for "enrichment learning" (bused in with other kids) from grade 6-12.
I tried pot for the first time at 12, was a typical stoner at 15, and went into the intellectual pursuit of "working in a kitchen" until my mid-20s.
My family was financially and socially stable enough that I could move back home with my parents at get a degree in Computer Science when various medical conditions prevented me from working as a cook any longer. I would have had a minor in "Math" had my university handed those out (they started a year after I graduated).
I in no way excelled. I had a decent GPA but it was hard work and my mature student status that got me through that first year back and kept me in it to get a degree. I couldn't handle being in university any longer so I dropped out of the Masters program.
I have I had gone to university right out of High School I probably would have failed and gone on the same path. My genius IQ did not set me up for curing cancer. It set me up for "I don't have to study to do well in school" and let me figure out "I can stage in different kitchens to travel around and see the world while also in a job that doesn't care if I am high all the time".
Giving me a guaranteed income would have probably stifled even that little bit of ambition.
I do think there's room for giving kids who didn't have the millions of squandered advantages I had some financial help but it should not be based on IQ.
- Workaccount2 4y agoSurely you understand that no matter what there will always be some amount of 130IQ+ people who languish their whole lives? A program like this is focused on the disproportionate number of home runs it would produce, fully expecting some to strike out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- diceduckmonk 4y ago> Giving me a guaranteed income would have probably stifled even that little bit of ambition. Well, are you still a cook now?
- zikzak 4y agoNo, I manage a bunch of dev teams. I'm lucky to be where I am. I don't think gbi would have helped me, I already had a privileged existence. My family is not wealthy but we faced no really economic insecurity and were all decent people. I'd rather see money go to people who have potential but not all the advantages I had. I just think IQ is a terrible predictor of "will cure cancer and invent a warp drive".
- nuncanada 4y agoIQ is the variable with most correlation for income at your 50s.... I have friends with extremely high IQ with a very similar path to yours...
- icedchai 4y agoI agree, the basic income should go elsewhere. Geniuses don't need it. Having a high IQ will guarantee you a privileged existence if you even apply yourself one little bit. Yeah, I know lots of high IQ people who are burn outs and do little-to-nothing for years on end... but that is also part of the privilege. They work when they want to.