3 ms·
What value did any of this provide to the world? Just reads like a buzzword soup where finance bros find more and more obscure ways to leach money.
by Gigachad 4y ago
What value did any of this provide to the world? Just reads like a buzzword soup where finance bros find more and more obscure ways to leach money.
- rglullis 4y agoDon't you guys get tired of rehashing the same baseless arguments over and over again? The value of decentralized platforms is that it gets rid of the tech bros and financial scams. Anyone, anywhere in the world, can make transactions independently, without having to blindly trust that the funds are actually there. If people transacted using DeFI, there would be no FTX, no Coinbase, no VC trying to leech off the masses.
- dmitriid 4y ago> The value of decentralized platforms is that it gets rid of the tech bros and financial scams. Ah yes. No scams or tech bros. Except the implicit blind trust in programs written in esoteric programming languages on esoteric VMs that are rife with financial scams. > If people transacted using DeFI, there would be no FTX, no Coinbase, no VC trying to leech off the masses. Except that Uniswap is currently almost 100% automated bots "swapping" fictional tokens. And for anything useful you depend on centralized oracles. And for anything related to actual real world you must go through centralized entities.
- lamp987 4y ago"And for anything useful you depend on centralized oracles." chainlink etc
- dmitriid 4y ago> chainlink etc Which are entirely dependent on centralised oracles etc. Hint: if there are only 2/5/10 centralised oracles providing you with data, no amount of fluffy "decentralised tamper-proof inputs" statements make them such.
- rglullis 4y ago> almost 100% automated bots "swapping" fictional tokens. Even if that was true (which it is not) it is still valuable for the people that use it and for the liquidity providers who can employ their capital in a reasonably safe manner without relying on banks.
- dmitriid 4y agoThere's no such thing as "liquidity" in these fantasy land tokens. The absolute vast majority of things happening on uniswap is indistinguishable from Forex and flash loans, only in these fantasy tokens.
- rglullis 4y agoI don't need to care about the "absolute vast majority" of the tokens to make use of Uniswap to exchange, e.g, Storj/BAT/ETH for DAI/USDC/EURS and to spend it for real goods. All I need is to have a market of people willing to trade. If you don't see the value of it, fine. But just go find someone who got their PayPal account frozen with no recourse and ask them how much they would value the ability to trade in a permissionless network.
- dmitriid 4y ago> I don't need to care about the "absolute vast majority" of the tokens to make use of Uniswap I didn't say "absolute vast majority of tokens". I said "absolute vast majority of things happening on uniswap". > All I need is to have a market of people willing to trade. There's absolutely a market for people willing to trade. If there wasn't, Amazon, eBay, AliExpress etc. wouldn't have been multi-trillion behemoths they are. Uniswap isn't a "market for people willing to trade". It's a market for people willing to engage in currency speculation and flash loans using fantasy tokens. Even you are saying this. Quote: "make use of Uniswap to exchange, e.g, Storj/BAT/ETH for DAI/USDC/EURS". There's nothing new or revolutionary in this.
- rglullis 4y ago
- chrisco255 4y agoAutomated Market Makers, like Uniswap, provide open, accessible, auditable, open source, extensible, liquidity to the world wide web. Anyone with an internet connection gets access to the market. Market access is taken for granted by Americans, but it should be noted that even here, Uniswap is superior to a NYSE or Nasdaq exchange along several vectors (openness, 24/7 availability, censorship resistance, full auditability, permissionless access, fair market making, etc). Tokens are also fully programmable, and that enables a number of primitives that are not possible with stock certificates or grain contracts. For one, they can easily be held within a multisig smart contract wallet, governed by configurable rules for spending (in an M-of-N scheme). This makes it frictionless to set up a small group or organization on the internet even if the participants are in 7 different countries. This helps to coordinate human and financial capital, because rules can be programmed in the DAO or multisig to prevent one person from stealing all the funds. Since everything is on-chain, everything is above the board. Very difficult to arrange this with traditional corporate checking accounts, and even then, one executive ultimately controls the account. Those two alone would be huge and worth it for humanity, but I listed more on that list and I'm running out of time for a reply. But I invite you to analyze the products yourself. Try them on testnets for free if you like.
- dmitriid 4y ago> This helps to coordinate human and financial capital, because rules can be programmed in the DAO or multisig "Rules can be programmed (in esoteric programming languages using new made up terms for everything)" and frictionless in one sentence. Smh.
- chrisco255 4y agoVery simple explanation: imagine you want to start a software company with 5 people you met on the internet. You each live in 5 different countries. How do you decide who holds the treasury? How do you decide which jurisdiction to register a partnership agreement in? There's a lot of friction there. And a lot of trust involved. Even if one person takes it upon themselves, the other 4 members have to trust the 1 guy in charge of the legal org & bank account won't rug pull on them and run off with the money or spend it needlessly. With a multisig smart contract wallet (https://gnosis-safe.io/ https://gnosis-safe.io/), it's frictionless to setup a simple smart contract for holding the treasury and for enacting M-of-N rules on any expenditures from that multisig. This may be a 3 of 5 signature requirement or even a 5 of 5 signature requirement. It's fully programmable. So when starting a Web3 project, it's possible to jump into a partnership with a group and be productive without having to worry as much about establishing trust, navigating five different jurisdictions for employment agreements, or centralizing control in a single person. In addition, far more elaborate org structures are possible, and there exist plenty of tooling for making those happen without even needing to know how to code (https://juicebox.money/ https://juicebox.money/, https://daohaus.club/ https://daohaus.club/). Solidity is not all that esoteric. It's similar in syntax to JavaScript, but it's statically typed. There are also widely recognized and audited open source code bases to build off of (https://www.openzeppelin.com/contracts https://www.openzeppelin.com/contracts). And tons of developer tooling (https://docs.ethers.io/v5/ https://docs.ethers.io/v5/, https://wagmi.sh/ https://wagmi.sh/), along with countless resources on the web.