3 ms·
It's pretty exciting to see such a big company pilot a data profit sharing program. Think of what it demonstrates. It acknowledges a standard that your persona
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
It's pretty exciting to see such a big company pilot a data profit sharing program.
Think of what it demonstrates. It acknowledges a standard that your personal data belongs to you, that they value it, and they are willing to pay you for it. More importantly, they are willing to do it in a upfront manner instead of trying to sneak it into some new application. Hopefully more companies will take note.
The whole premise of data privacy is that your data belongs to you, to do with it what you want, including selling it.
I'm normally very privacy-minded but tempted to agree to it just on a matter of principle to help get such a market off the ground.
- heavyset_go 4y agoI wouldn't call this profit sharing, exactly. It's more akin to a fixed wage or fee than profit sharing.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI dont want to get bogged down in technicality, so call it what you want. They think they can make money on the data and willing to pay a user for the data that they use. I haven't seen that before in the general consumer space.
- sublinear 4y ago> The whole premise of data privacy is that your data belongs to you, to do with it what you want, including selling it. Nice try
- s1artibartfast 4y agoPeople have discussed companies paying for personal data for a long time and I think this is an exciting step in the right direction. Not sure what your low effort comment is trying to say. That people shouldn't be able to sell their data?
- reb 4y agoSpeculation: they might be questioning the implication that a paid surveillance program pushes data privacy/ownership values forward. Paying folks to be surveilled might be better than surveilling them without consent or reward, but it does incentivize the normalization of surveillance. And, depending on your economic beliefs, one could make the case it weaponizes the threat of poverty to drive that normalization.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThanks for the constructive and insightful comment. I think there is some value to that perspective. My main disagreement is that in the US at least, I feel that corporate surveillance is already normalized. Given that, I think this is an incremental step away from non-consensual surveillance, or at least surveillance where the transactional aspect isn't obvious. Most people are already tracked by their phone apps, google, ect. It is normalized.
- reb 4y agoThat's fair. I think, despite the normalization, there is still a general feeling the surveillance is non-consensual, and that basic skepticism might actually be more valuable than a meager payout for now-consensual surveillance. At $2/month, the exchange doesn't really do anything but pay to normalize the idea of a consumer market for selling your personal data. And as other comments on the post have pointed out, this is just the starting point. If people will consent to x for $2, consenting to y for $4 or $10 or $50 dollars is officially on the bargaining table. Deeper and deeper behavioral data will only become more desirable as the AI arms race heats up, so I'm confident we can expect surveillance demands to grow in the coming years. The outcomes for personal data markets are self-evident. I'm not about to agitate for laws against programs like these, but I don't think they're a good thing for society and they seem quite contrary to anything privacy advocates stand in favor of.
- zephyros 4y ago> And, depending on your economic beliefs, one could make the case it weaponizes the threat of poverty to drive that normalization. As another commenter point out, this eerily reminds me of human organs trafficking. "People own their body, so shouldn't they be allowed to sell their organ?". We don't allow such things because this directly impacts people with low-income. Now admittedly one's organ is not comparable to one's information, but my stance on this is that privacy should be human rights, non negotiable.
- altairprime 4y agoIf they only value me at $2/month, then I’d rather deprive them of $2/month than value myself at $2/month.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't think Amazon has any estimation of your valu as human being- it isn't personal. If someone asked to pick out the cans from my recycling, I don't see that as a critique of my personal value.
- altairprime 4y agoI do, if they’re labeling each can with my house number and scanning it into a database – which (in that analogy) is what Amazon is doing here.
- jacob019 4y agoI fear that there is a predatory nature to the transaction--that the strong is preying on the dumb.
- midoridensha 4y agoI wish they'd offer some money to spy on my use of various web services. For instance, I'd happily take $5/month to let them spy on my usage of Twitter. I don't use Twitter, so it would be a free $5/month!