4 ms·
The Roof Always Caves In: Why there is nothing wrong with being doomed
- leaving 4y ago
- DanHulton 4y agoIt's like you didn't read the article, and only saw the parts about Christianity, and bounced back here to complain about it. Religion is but the least part of this, the larger focus is on community and how important that truly is. Also, why all the assumptions and anger about the cancer diagnosis? That is also the least part of it. You don't need to know the deep details to reluctantly agree with their doctor in order to get context for the rest of the tale. For what it's worth, I'm an athiest as well, and much like many things that do not perfectly describe me, I can still find value in this if I stretch my imagination a bit. Religious people have not cornered the market on community, they just seem to be one of the last bastions of it in North America, where our individuality tends to take the forefront. But much as this is, as the author points out, an opportunity for Christians to lead by example and display the benefits and values of community, it's an opportunity for the rest of us to espouse the same, just from a secular point of view. There's real benefits to be gained there.
- quinnjh 4y agoThis was a refreshing mix. author discussing theology, sacrifice, and tradition, and ALSO simone de beauvoir in the same piece. If de Beauvoir was accepted as canon one might expect to see catholic divorce rates drop.
- n4r9 4y agoThat's a surprising comment. As a lifelong unflinching atheist who criticised the institution of marriage and thought that religion oppressed women, I wouldn't have said de Beauvoir provides much for Catholics to relate to. Unless you meant it as a joke, i.e. if more people read de Beauvoir, there'd be fewer Catholics. Could you elaborate?
- PicassoCTs 4y agoEh, internally perceived doomed societies sparked some of the worst world wars we know. The nazis were out of fertilizer, the japanese out of everything and the great game of empires made only autarky seem as a viable option. Thus began the great butcheries between the upstarts and latecomers, and the established players that was WW1 and WW2. Three cheers for the providers of fertilizers, untaxed international trade and the atomic bomb, keeping the peace. They do look awfully pale and thin on those old photos for a reason. So to not struggle against a caving in roof, is the attempt to return to the old state of the world, which was horrible. This is not a viable philosophic position for somebody wielding any power to affect change.
- mantas 4y agoAwfully thin as in not obese like today?
- DarmokJalad1701 4y agoNo. Awfully thin as in malnourished.
- monero-xmr 4y agoI agree we are all interdependent and no man is an island. The paradoxical thing is that what makes humanity special is that everyone is unique, we are all individuals with our own opinions, and if we were all part of a monoculture then we wouldn’t have much of a culture at all. When times are tough (as this author is unfortunately going through) your support networks are crucial. Family, friends, and (if you have it) your faith in god. This is earned however - if you have lived a miserly, unhappy life then don’t be surprised that few show up when you are in need. You need to show reciprocity and be a good brother, friend, and community member when times are good as well. I don’t discount how hyper important the individual is - it’s extremely hard and isolating to raise your hand in class, publish a contrarian idea, start a business, ask someone on a date, be a stand up comedian, write and perform music, and all manner of things that you yourself must get the courage to do. And these actions are what move society forwards most. There doesn’t have to be a dividing wall between the individual and the community. You grow your support network by watering it like a garden, weeding out the bad plants, protecting it from poor weather. You have that as your base upon which to build towering castles.
- RHSman2 4y agoNicely put. Basically, as I get older (46) I see how we change our environment by our actions. We influence (good and bad)
- glofish 4y agobut maybe what you see is what you are made to see the constant harping and relentless barrage of information that every major storm, landslide or flood "could have been" caused by humanity itself yes we should be more careful and we are - and nature is much better shape than years ago - think about the massive deforestation in Pennsylvania at the turn of century, it was a barren wasteland, today it is 70% forested with millions of acres of unbroken forests yet none of that good news is ever presented, it is always about things at the brink
- verisimi 4y agoI agree with a lot of what you said - that individuality is what drives us forward. But, in my view, acceptance of individuals and their damn unpopular opinions is exactly what is under attack. The last 2 or 3 years were not a great time for the individual. The 'community' was stampeding, morality and freedom of choice went out of the window, and it didn't matter who got hurt. Everyone needed to do what they were told. So, what I'm hearing is 'fine words' but these seem to go out of the window, when the s** appears to hit the fan. Ultimately - this is a question of authority. Are you your own authority, or do experts (political, judicial, scientific, etc) tell you what to do?
- Jaydon564 4y ago[flagged]
- smackeyacky 4y agoYet another christian accidentally discovers judaism in scripture.
- JackFr 4y ago> We add and subtract for radiators and replacement cars, and when the dishwasher vomits all the soapy, dirty water onto the hardwood (only ever when we are on vacation), we don’t feel lucky, but we are. What an absolutely delightful piece. Not typical HN fare but lovely.
- smackeyacky 4y agoYet another christian accidentally discovers judaism in scripture
- geophile 4y agoBecause of the first part of that title, I read the last word as "domed".
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI am always puzzled (yet not puzzled) that someone would frame what this piece seems to be about in terms of their own personal theology. Everything in this beautifully written piece rings true to me, and yet somehow the connection to Christianity, either as a source of that truth or as an expression of it, feels forced. You don't need to be a Christian to have had the author's experiences and desires, and you don't need to be a Christian to share an understanding of "the way forward". I remain puzzled about what precisely the author believes Christianity itself brings to the questions and life situations she is writing about, above and beyond what the simple act of being a self-aware human can.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoTheir frame, their world view is based or heavily influenced by their faith, which drives their decisions, comments, dispositions, and this article of self-expression. It reads like you are stating that their personal, self-expression does not require their own world view, therefore it should have been left out. Do I read your note correctly? If so, I disagree. Yes, the whole article could have been written in a few paragraphs. In my opinion, it would have been dull, lack nuance, and failed to color-in the emotions she felt.
- taeric 4y agoI think I agree with the OP. I'm happy for folks that find comfort in the company they decide to keep. I am always confused by the idea that this is somehow the religion a person chooses that is the deciding factor. Take the first callout, "I have always believed that one of the great arguments for being part of a collectivist Christian tradition is their willingness to do voluntary, gruelling manual labour and call it love." What about that actually requires the "Christian" part? And the odd implication that other collectivist traditions would not find a path to volunteering is... a little chilling to me.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI didn't want it to be shorter. I just think she could have explored all the same themes and told all the same anecdotes without any of them explicitly being connected to Christianity. Except, perhaps, for the willingness of communitarian anabaptists to do hard work as a group, but even then, how much of that relates to their Christian faith and how much to their communitarian outlook (something they share with non-Christian groups).
- caradine 4y agoAs a non-religious person descended from Mennonites, I felt something strong when she said: > I have always believed that one of the great arguments for being part of a collectivist Christian tradition is their willingness to do voluntary, gruelling manual labour and call it love. However, I was disappointed that the piece concluded in an evangelical call to action, littered with evangelical buzzwords I've heard a hundred times: > ... tremendous opportunity ... foster community ... in the midst of this fear of our own vulnerability ... Our neighbours ... needing language for the pain ... searching for meaning ... tell them the truth As a transgender person, I know that the community they want to foster comes with way too many conditions.
- pierrebai 4y agoI'm going to be a contrarian here, but I felt really annoyed reading this piece about an extremely privileged person, living in a privileged country, with an expensive education, holding a prestigious job at a famous journal listing her woes, while exposing how high-cultured she is by name dropping Kierkegaard, de Beauvoir and de Toqueville... meanwhile people freeze in Ukraine [1] and get killed and raped in their own home in Port-au-Prince [2]. Yes, you can accuse me of what-about-ism. I still think and have always thought that while one's very allowed to gaze back at themselves, it is better done in private or amongst friends. Doing so in public never elegant, IMO. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63868158 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63868158 [2] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-63707429 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-63707429
- olddustytrail 4y agoI have to admit, and probably just because it is on HN, I initially assumed from the title that this article was about Dwarf Fortress.