3 ms·
> under the old Wade-Giles romanization system the city was transliterated as 'Peking' Not even close. Under the old Wade-Giles system the name of the city is
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> under the old Wade-Giles romanization system the city was transliterated as 'Peking'
Not even close. Under the old Wade-Giles system the name of the city is transliterated as 'pei-ching'. That is because, as you note, the pronunciation in Mandarin didn't change. You seem to be imagining a sound that might be interpreted as a K or, alternatively, might be interpreted as a J, but there is no such sound.
- glxxyz 4y agoWell, at least close-er, yes the 'k' is older than Wade Giles, the changes in spelling are still just changes in romanizations systems.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoNo, that's not correct. The 'k' in Peking is there because Peking is not a transcription from Mandarin. The change was in what language to use for the name of the city, not in what romanization system to use.
- glxxyz 4y agoI didn't say the k was a romanization, I said it was older.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- glxxyz 4y ago> You seem to be imagining a sound that might be interpreted as a K or, alternatively, might be interpreted as a J No, not at all
- thaumasiotes 4y ago>>> The pronunciation in Mandarin never changed, just the way that sounds which don't have any exact equivalent in our alphabet are represented. What did you mean by this? It was your only comment, other than a factual error, on a contrast of the name "Peking" with the name "Beijing".