3 ms·
> If you are an American, you already have a federally issued ID it just isn’t very good. What ID is that? If you're talking about a Social Security Card, tha
by kelnos 4y ago
> If you are an American, you already have a federally issued ID it just isn’t very good.
What ID is that? If you're talking about a Social Security Card, that's not ID at all. I don't think I would call it "ID but not very good", even.
Ultimately there are a lot of people who go through life in the US who never have a federally-issued ID at all. Simply never traveling outside the US will do it for most people. And there are more people than you'd expect in the US who never leave the country.
Also agree re: voting: elections are administered by states, so a federal ID is just not even necessary here. States are perfectly capable of issuing ID, as we all know. (Granted, drivers licenses and non-driving state IDs usually don't have anything to say about citizenship status. A state-issued ID serves as authentication, not authorization, where voting is concerned.)
- Godel_unicode 4y agoIn what way is your social security card not an ID? It is used as a credential to identify yourself, and is one of very few such identifiers that most organizations take (i.e. I can use it to get many other IDs). Many state DMVs list it on a page called “identity documents”. All Americans have been issued their card at least once, and more to the point not having the card doesn’t mean you don’t have the ID as many people will take the number. It’s a very weak ID for a lot of reasons, but that fact alone doesn’t make it not one. It just makes it a dangerous one. Why are you against having a good one?
- andrewflnr 4y agoFunctionally, a social security number is closer to an alternate name than an ID. It doesn't contain evidence that can feasibly be used to prove that the person showing it to you is who they claim to be, the way the picture/physical descriptors on a photo ID card do. And it's not even an unpredictable name, so you can't even treat it the way you would a long unpredictable token in a security context.
- Godel_unicode 4y ago> social security number is closer to an alternate name `s/is/should be/` If I have your social security card I can pretend to be you quite effectively as many people will accept it as an ID. They don’t care that you don’t think it is one. The ones that don’t will frequently take an alternative (read: derived) that I can get with just it. > It doesn't contain evidence that can feasibly be used to prove… Yes. We agree, it’s a bad ID.
- ghaff 4y agoWhat places requiring government-issued photo ID will accept a social security card? Sure, you can social engineer lots of things, but I'm very skeptical that presenting a social security card in place of a driver's license or passport will generally pass muster. Though don't actually know as I haven't had one in decades.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoYou added an artificial constraint by specifying photo ID. I never claimed that a social security card is a photo ID because clearly it isn’t. You do have one, or if you insist you were issued one, you just don’t possess it.
- ghaff 4y agoAny place requesting a government issued ID expects a photo ID.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoThe state of West Virginia will give you a (non-RealID) drivers license with a social security card and 2 pieces of mail. Card to prove your identity and mail to prove that name went with a W.Va address. At one point the lifelock guy had something like 200 W.Va licenses since in the mid-aughts they didn’t actually check to see if that SSN had a license already. W.Va license gets you a passport. Passport gets you anything you want. The only thing standing between you and full-blown has-a-passport identity theft is your Social Security Card. Edit: You can intuitively prove that everywhere doesn’t require a photo ID because some piece of ID has to come first.