4 ms·
After being given this information, a reasonable person would conclude that while smoking might decrease their risk of getting COVID, starting a smoking habit (
by kelnos 4y ago
After being given this information, a reasonable person would conclude that while smoking might decrease their risk of getting COVID, starting a smoking habit (possibly leading to addiction) would mean likely worse health outcomes than just accepting the risk of getting COVID (which can be lowered significantly through much safer means).
Unfortunately, there are lot of unreasonable people out there. I would not be surprised if a ton of people, if they were to hear the WHO or CDC agree that smoking reduces the risk of COVID infection, would start smoking, and get addicted. Some of those who were already addicted and were trying to quit would decide to stop trying.
The issue is that this information seems to have been suppressed, censored, and outright lied about by authorities. Now, on one hand, I get it: organizations like the WHO and CDC are not only interested in the raw outcomes of trials and research, but are also responsible for influencing public health policy. I think it's pretty safe to say that telling people smoking helps protect from COVID would be against public health goals.
I honestly don't know where I stand on this. I think I'm fine with orgs like the WHO and CDC deliberately not making recommendations on, or being silent about, things that they don't believe are healthy to encourage. But outright lying, denying the results of trials that do prove a correlation, crosses the line for me.
- brookst 4y agoAgree, with the nuance that I think the psychology at WHO / CDC / etc is probably focused on existing smokers who may choose not to (try to) quit because of data like this ("WHO says I should keep smoking!") But there are going to be misinterpretations and bad outcomes no matter what. So I'd err on the side of honesty and integrity, and perhaps trying to mitigate harm by producing data on, say, life expectancies for smokers who quit today versus those who don't, and (presumably) the data that says it's still way better to quit. And if the data doesn't support that, well, data is data.
- janalsncm 4y agoI think the most likely outcome is for a certain subset of the population to think “I don’t need to get vaccinated, I smoke cigarettes.”
- ipaddr 4y agoAnd they would have been right.
- hiimkeks 4y agoNo they wouldn't. Smoking gives a little protection against infection, but once you have it it's likely much worse. Vaccines give you a little protection against infection and also reduce the probability of severe courses of illness.
- ipaddr 4y ago50-68% more protection which is better than the vaccine. And it did provide better outcomes when patients were treated with patches in the hospital.
- WhackyIdeas 4y agoIt seems controversial even saying this, and a bit absurd… But I am a heavy smoker and have somehow managed to dodge Covid so far. It is probably coincidence, but I would love it to be studied into more no matter how inconvenient it may be…
- akimball 4y agoI'm a non-smoker but use nicotine daily. My mother (nicotine free) died of COVID, but I have never had it. But we are mere anecdotes, and prove nothing.
- WhackyIdeas 4y agoSorry to hear about your loss. I haven’t experienced loss on that scale yet.
- chasil 4y agoIt would be interesting to see what impact nicotine tablets had on infection outcomes. A longer-term study on dementia would also be helpful. Nicotine is expressed by plants as a pesticide, but the effect on humans is obviously more nuanced. There might be beneficial effects, especially if the delivery mechanism does not involve setting anything on fire.