3 ms·
Head injuries are also the most common thing that kills drivers. Your argument provides an equally strong case that drivers should be required to wear helmets.
by jeffbee 4y ago
Head injuries are also the most common thing that kills drivers. Your argument provides an equally strong case that drivers should be required to wear helmets.
The hierarchy of helmet need is #1 motorcyclists, #2 drivers, #3 pedestrians–pedestrian head injuries are incredibly common–, and #4 cyclists.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoThe first couple of pages in this doc substantiate your claim (for Portland) at least: https://www.portland.gov/sites/default/files/2022/traffic-crash-report-2021.pdf https://www.portland.gov/sites/default/files/2022/traffic-cr...
- jeffbee 4y agoWell, that is interesting, but head injuries are often from just falling over from any height, not really from being hit by cars. Most traumatic brain injuries in older adults are from falling from standing height or less.
- chollida1 4y ago> The hierarchy of helmet need is #1 motorcyclists, #2 drivers, #3 pedestrians–pedestrian head injuries are incredibly common–, and #4 cyclists. Interesting. I would have assumed cyclists are second given how fast road bikes go and the fact that they normally ride on major roads where cars speeds are well above 60 km/hr. How did you arrive at your ordering? Was it from an unlinked source?
- jeffbee 4y agoI'm just going from national injury stats you can find in CDC WONDER and derived reports. Head injuries among American cyclists are a non-issue, far behind practically all other causes of head injuries, and using government powers to force cyclists to wear helmets is a complete waste of everyone's time. My go-to reference for this is https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10053381/1/Mindell_Cause%20of%20death%20ppr%20R2_18Jun2018_Accepted.pdf https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10053381/1/Mindell_Cau... but if you want to translate it from UK to USA you have to do it yourself.
- chollida1 4y agoI appreciate the link, but I can't tell if those number are per capita or just raw numbers. It would make sense that bike numbers are smaller if they are just the raw numbers given that there are probably 100x more cyclists and 1000x more pedestrians than bikers. If those numbers aren't adjusted for usage then it makes bikes look even more dangerous when you adjust for how often each form of travel is used. As someone who commutes by bike, yikes!!
- AdrianB1 4y agoI am both a motorcycle rider and a bicycle rider for decades. While I never-ever got on the motorcycle without a helmet, half of my bicycle rides on the road are without a helmet and the only reason I wear one ever is because it has better venting than a regular cotton cap. I always wear a helmet offroad on the bicycle. The day the helmet will be mandatory on a bicycle I will sell by bikes, it means cycling is too dangerous to be on a street and the government is incapable of protecting cyclists but by mandating helmets. It's like mandating bulletproof vests in Philadelphia or Baltimore instead of solving the gun violence problem in the cities.
- chollida1 4y ago> While I never-ever got on the motorcycle without a helmet, half of my bicycle rides on the road are without a helmet and the only reason I wear one ever is because it has better venting than a regular cotton cap. I always wear a helmet offroad on the bicycle. Interesting, why don't you wear a helmet on the road? I assume the reason you always wear a helmet off road is because of all the falls on trails?
- AdrianB1 4y agoI think that cycling on road (not road racing) should be safe enough not to need a helmet; if it does, I don't go on that trip. If I cannot safely use a bicycle around town without a helmet it means a child cannot ever use a bike safely. Offroad I voluntarily take moderate risks, so I always wear a helmet and gloves (gloves are more for comfort) and sometimes an enduro "light armor" to protect me from tree branches on a single trail. But the equipment I wear is 100% my decision and I want to stay that way.
- chollida1 4y agoI appreciate that response. The only thing I have issues with is this statement. > I think that cycling on road (not road racing) should be safe enough not to need a helmet; if it does, I don't go on that trip. Would you say the same thing about seatbelts in a car? I just can't figure out how to wrap my mind around not taking a trip if you need safety gear with one mode of transportation and not another. Fully agree about it should be each person's individual decision. And nice to run into another cyclist on this site!!
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoThe classic argument is that people should be wearing bike helmets when climbing ladders, using stairs and having a shower (a lot of people slip in the shower). However, when examined logically in terms of head protection, people think that it's only appropriate for cyclists.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoIf you are basing on totally detached statistics, maybe.. But what's obviously missing is context. Safety is all about context. Walking shouldn't require protection until excessive risk is added to it, like walking on ice or across a busy intersection. The moment that risk is added, it needs to be balanced with safety. Helmets might be an effective safety measure, but they are situationally inconvenient for pedestrians; and rely on too much behavioral discipline.
- alistairSH 4y agoWalking shouldn't require protection until excessive risk is added to it, like walking ... across a busy intersection. It's next to impossible in the US to walk anywhere useful (transport vs recreation) without crossing a busy intersection.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoYes, I don't mean to say that's uncommon. My point is that helmets aren't the method generally chosen to mitigate that risk.
- oblio 4y ago> Head injuries are also the most common thing that kills drivers I wonder what the correlation is with seatbelt usage. My guess is that most people who die of head injuries due so because they're not wearing a seatbelt, and the head doesn't take kindly to being turned into the tip of a meat missile.