The lawsuit is alleging that he is being penalized for cheating in a game that he did not cheat. Afaik, nobody is arguing that you can't punish somebody for br

The lawsuit is alleging that he is being penalized for cheating in a game that he did not cheat. Afaik, nobody is arguing that you can't punish somebody for breaking a rule. He even was banned in the past for cheating. However, you can't use an already punished infraction to issue a second infraction. Hans is claiming that he's been blacklisted from a bunch of tournaments as a result of a very unproven claim he cheated in the Sinquefield Cup.